The Forge Archives

Independent Game Forums => Adept Press => Topic started by: Ron Edwards on November 17, 2003, 09:39:31 AM

Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: Ron Edwards on November 17, 2003, 09:39:31 AM
Hello,

For the first time in a while, the Trollbabe Comics (http://www.adept-press.com/trollbabe/comics.html) page is finally fully stocked - all the previous stories, and the start of a new one.

Yup, "Dusty Musty Wisdom" is finished. Yes, Jesse, I know you hated it. I hope someone (anyone) else liked it. James Linares did great work with the art.

And this week begins with the first strip of "The Naked Helpless Sacrifice Scene," starring Retta, illustrated by Colin Theriot.

Best,
Ron
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: jburneko on November 17, 2003, 12:25:03 PM
Hey now, let's not be hasty...

I didn't hate it.  I hated how it began.  Actually, I thought it was pretty cool how it ended.  You should have seen the look on my face when Tha snapped her fingers and made the ghost go away.  I thought, "Damn, why'd she throw away something so useful?"

It's what I like about the way you've portrayed Tha.  There's a rashness there that I enjoy.

Jesse
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: Ron Edwards on November 17, 2003, 12:41:32 PM
Ha! Got ya.

I like both Tha and Retta - the former is rash because she wants something, and the latter is rash because she doesn't know what she wants. They both try to do good things as they go, but their personal agendas are their real sources of conflict.

As I have discovered along the route of writing these things, anyway. At least, I hope it's visible to others at some level, regardless of the amount of humor and/or horror involved.

Best,
Ron
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: Ron Edwards on November 24, 2003, 10:42:36 AM
Colin's second strip is up for "The Naked Helpless Sacrifice Scene" story!

It's beautiful work.

Best,
Ron
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: Rod Anderson on November 24, 2003, 01:07:21 PM
Colin's strips look great! Very moody and atmospheric, which really comes out in this week's wordless strip.

I'm tempted to speculate that Rus is two-timing his patron animal, but surely that's some other malefactor in the bat hat, there.


Rod
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: Ron Edwards on December 01, 2003, 01:18:02 PM
Hi there,

Well, that's not Rus. I guess all the cultist leaders have goatees.

But Rus is certainly due for a comeback one of these days.

Best,
Ron
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: Colin the Riot on December 06, 2003, 04:54:50 PM
It's BAD GUYS.  BAD GUYS have goatees.  Can't just limit yourself to cult-leaders.  That's pigeonholing for Chrissakes!
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: Colin the Riot on December 16, 2003, 01:43:34 AM
Anyone have any feedback on the strips I'm doing?  Be honest.  First time I've tried something like this.
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: ejh on December 16, 2003, 06:26:15 PM
They make me wish I knew how to draw/paing using tones like that.  I really like it. :)


How do you do it, man?  Sheer technique I mean.
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: Colin the Riot on December 16, 2003, 09:29:07 PM
Quote from: ejhThey make me wish I knew how to draw/paing using tones like that.  I really like it. :)

How do you do it, man?  Sheer technique I mean.

Well, I start with either a white or black background depending on the lighting of the scene.  Then I put in the larger shapes with the opposite color (white on black, black on white).  That produces a "sketch" kind of.  After that, it's just about picking a light source and refining layer on top of layer on top of layer.  Typically, I'll do 50% grey first, then 25% on either side to "carve" out the shapes I want.

These are done digitally, by the way.  I have a Wacom Tablet and I draw in Photoshop.  Check out my site if you want to see more of my work.  And thanks very much for the response.  

Any criticism?  I've never made an attempt at this type of storytelling, so I'd like to know if I'm doing okay with the visual pacing and tone.
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: greyorm on December 16, 2003, 10:17:48 PM
Looking good so far.

Ron's really the guy to ask about the pacing (being his comic), but it seems to me that having three strips involving the unfolding of the same situation is too much for a weekly story.

Strip One: I'm tied up by cultists
Strip Two: I'm still tied up by cultists
Strip Three: I'm beating up cultists

I would think one strip would have covered it pretty well, or probably, two, as I had to jump back to the previous two strips to figure out what was going on in the third. But that's coming from a guy who has never done comic strips, either, so "grain of salt" and all that.
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: Ron Edwards on December 16, 2003, 11:02:22 PM
Sorry guys, this story's pretty much all about being tied up by cultists and beating up cultists, not much else. All pacing and content-per-strip issues are my fault.

Working with Colin is interesting - I do very much appreciate seeing the intermediate steps of the work, and it's a good opportunity for back-and-forth about what the final version will look like. But a lot of the folks who do primarily computer-work aren't used to that, and it takes a little time to convince them that I really do know that the final version will be much more highly rendered. I love working with thumbnails, boards, and other "structure only" preliminary artwork.

For the record, the strip where Retta kicks the guy in the face has incredible "camera angle" technique from panel to panel. And that's all you, Colin.

Best,
Ron
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: Colin the Riot on December 17, 2003, 12:56:14 AM
Quote from: Ron Edwards
*snip*

But a lot of the folks who do primarily computer-work aren't used to that, and it takes a little time to convince them that I really do know that the final version will be much more highly rendered. I love working with thumbnails, boards, and other "structure only" preliminary artwork.

For the record, the strip where Retta kicks the guy in the face has incredible "camera angle" technique from panel to panel. And that's all you, Colin.

Best,
Ron

Speaking as an exclusive computer art person, I say that we aren't used to that because more often than not you'll show preliminaries to someone and they'll comment on how it's not finished.  I dunno if it's that lines that look this way would be permanent in more traditional art, so they assume you're complete, or what.  I've just gotten so tired of having to re-stress "work in progress" that I say it up-front for good measure.  

That, and my "sketches" are a a kind of graphic shorthand, and are the equivalent of doctor's signatures.  The sketch I show is about 10 steps more worked than what I eed to "mark my place" and I've gotten into the habit of prefacing that as well.

Then again, I'm also used to showing my work to average joes rather than people who commission artwork on a regular basis.  I've come to trust more in others ability to see a finished product from my preliminaries.

And thank you for the compliment on the angles.  I do try to keep a "camera" in mind for most drawings, and it comes from a combination of things.  Training, and personal preference mostly.
Marvel comics, life drawing courses, photograpy courses.  I'm not a fan of "pose" style work, so I try to make something happen in every strip.

And greyorm, not to nitpick but it's:
Strip One: I'm passing out after a battle
Strip Two: I'm passed out and dragged away by cultists
Strip Three: I wake up and discover I'm tied up by cultists in the last panel.
Strip Four: I free myself in the first panel and then kick the big bad in the face.
Strip Five: I beat up cultists and choke the Big Bad.

Retta's tied down for two panels total.  Sorry if my art wasn't clearer there.  It's explicitly panel-by-panel in Ron's script.

And I seriously like discussing my work, so please don't hesitate to chime in.  Criticism helps me get better. :)
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: jrs on December 17, 2003, 11:45:02 AM
Colin,

I have been enjoying your work in the latest Trollbabe strip.   I like the pseudo woodcut look of it.  I recall thinking that either the first or second strip was a little too uniformly dark, but I cannot double-check that because they have rotated off the site.  By far my favorite is strip no. 4, with the face kicking panel.  I agree with Ron about the angles, but I also like the way you incorporated background talk, foreground talk, story commentary (the "Holy Mackerel" line), and sound effects.  

Julie
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: greyorm on December 18, 2003, 01:08:15 AM
Colin,

Definitely casting no aspersions on your technique! I agree with Ron, the viewing angles are nothing short of excellent. As to the strip numbering: sorry about that -- I haven't seen the first two strips you mentioned yet.
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: Colin the Riot on December 18, 2003, 11:18:01 AM
Quote from: jrsColin,

I have been enjoying your work in the latest Trollbabe strip.   I like the pseudo woodcut look of it.  I recall thinking that either the first or second strip was a little too uniformly dark, but I cannot double-check that because they have rotated off the site.  By far my favorite is strip no. 4, with the face kicking panel.  I agree with Ron about the angles, but I also like the way you incorporated background talk, foreground talk, story commentary (the "Holy Mackerel" line), and sound effects.  

Julie

I noticed the darkness in strip 2 as well.  Only not until it went up and I saw it from work.  I guess my monitor is just bright at home.  I'd like to host the whole story on my site as well once it's complete, and I intend to correct the brightness level in the strip then.

Strip 4 was the most complex stip in the story, so I'm glad it came out well.  Thanks for the feedback!
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: Valamir on December 18, 2003, 11:22:00 AM
Hey Ron, was Rhetta's last line about the god's name to demonstrate what a rube these wannabe cultists are, or was that a reference/homage to someone I'm not aware of.
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: Ron Edwards on December 18, 2003, 12:30:36 PM
Hi Ralph,

The story still has three or four strips to run; all will be revealed.

Best,
Ron
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: Christopher Kubasik on January 06, 2004, 03:40:45 PM
Hi Colin,

I just wanted to compliment your work as well.  The woodcut look, while still retaining a solid feel of mass, was fantastic.  (My favorite bit -- the "blurred" chain rushing past me in the foreground.... You really nailed an amazing sense of motion there.)

This might of been brought up before, but what did you use?  It looks like colored markers of different values, but I can't be sure.

Best,
Christopher
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: Colin the Riot on January 07, 2004, 09:20:50 PM
Quote from: Christopher KubasikHi Colin,

I just wanted to compliment your work as well.  The woodcut look, while still retaining a solid feel of mass, was fantastic.  (My favorite bit -- the "blurred" chain rushing past me in the foreground.... You really nailed an amazing sense of motion there.)

This might of been brought up before, but what did you use?  It looks like colored markers of different values, but I can't be sure.

Best,
Christopher

Thank you very much.  I'm glad that blur came out okay.  It looked weird before I added it, like the chain was just hanging there.

As for what I use, it's all done digitally with a Wacom Graphire tablet and Photoshop.  I haven't used real art supplies in about 6 years, and I find it really freeing.  It's not for everyone, but if not for this way of working, I wouldn't be making art at all.  With this way of working, I've been published four times, and have a (fairly) long runnning comic strip of my own.

If you want more detail on my work methods, I'd be happy to discuss it if you want to PM me.  Thanks again for the compliments.
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: Christopher Kubasik on January 08, 2004, 01:36:53 AM
Wow.

Thanks a lot.  When I have an intelligent question I'll make sure to get back to you.  Thanks for the offer.

Christopher
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: ejh on January 10, 2004, 05:23:48 PM
I've got a question, intelligent or not -- what kind of machine?  What kind of processor/whatever do you find necessary to be comfortable for drawing?  Apple or Wintel?  And what resolution do you work at?

Danke. :)
Title: Trollbabe comics: old story down, new story up
Post by: Bob McNamee on January 10, 2004, 09:46:50 PM
Ok, I'm not Colin (love the art by the way Colin!)

But I do some art on the Computer too.

Both machines are fine for computer art...and the same programs are now available for both machines, more or less.

I use Painter, myself. Usually I work at 300 dpi, then downsize for strictly on-computer uses (like webgraphics)[edit downsize to 72 dpi-websize]

Wacom tablets are available for both computers.
Both  Photoshop (Adobe) and Painter (Corel -lately) are available for both machines. They originated on the Mac and migrated to the PC in the mid 90's. They are a bit pricey, but very good.($200-$500? haven't priced them lately)

The programs?
Painter was much more for duplicating natural-media artworking (watercolor, oils,ink etc) looks and feel,while Photoshop was more well suited to adjusting and manipulating Photographic material...

But, now they both are capable of doing many of the same things, with a bit practice.

I use a PC, due to cost more a than anything. Pentium 3 and 4 work great...you can't ever have enough RAM, or disk space. But I used to do things with Painter 4 on a Pentium(1) 133 with 16 megs of RAM...

I'm the slow part of the system...deciding what to do next  :)