News:

Forum changes: Editing of posts has been turned off until further notice.

Main Menu

Dice probabilities question and meta-question

Started by Robert Bohl, August 14, 2006, 01:27:45 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Hans

Quote from: David Artman on August 24, 2006, 12:04:17 PM
Quote from: stack0v3rflow on August 14, 2006, 02:18:59 PMI'm not sure what you are looking for, but to find the average of a die you take the number of sides, divide by two and add 0.5.  So a 1d4 will roll a 2.5 average.
That gets you the median (mean?) value, not the average. For the average, I think one sums the lowest value and highest value, then divides by two.

Suppose a die rolls from 0 to 9? Your method delivers an average of 5.5, when it's actually 4.5.

This first method assumes highest value = number of sides, which is true for a d10 if you consider the 0 a 10, as most games do.  Your method is more broadly correct, as long as each value appears the same number of times.  For any fair die, the mean = median.
* Want to know what your fair share of paying to feed the hungry is? http://www3.sympatico.ca/hans_messersmith/World_Hunger_Fair_Share_Number.htm
* Want to know what games I like? http://www.boardgamegeek.com/user/skalchemist

Blankshield

Quote from: RobNJ on August 14, 2006, 01:27:45 PM
2) Does this matter?  Am I going to get anything useful from looking at these distributions?  Should I just go with my gut and have it playtested?

(PS: On the drive home from Gen Con I wrote the complete notes/outline of a game.)

Hi Rob,

To answer question 2: Yes, it matters; in games with dice, dice mechanics affect the shape of play greatly.  However, you probably don't need to know curves and probabilities and all the rest of that, except in very broad terms.  I would suggest you're going about this a little bit backwards:

In the context of your game, find out what effect you want the dice to have, both in terms of possible range and effect and probably outcomes.  Then develope on the mechanic that does that, playtest it to confirm it matches expectations.  Lacerate, rinse, repeat.

Dice mechanics and probability curves are fun (for some people) and useful to know as a tool in your designer's belt, but without the context of the game it's going to be in, it's basically mathamatical wanking.

So... what's your game idea?  (probably best for a new thread, esp. since it seems you've gotten your answer to #1)

James
I write games. My games don't have much in common with each other, except that I wrote them.

http://www.blankshieldpress.com/

Robert Bohl

Game:
Misspent Youth: Ocean's 11 + Avatar: The Last Airbender + Snow Crash
Shows:
Oo! Let's Make a Game!: Joshua A.C. Newman and I make a transhumanist RPG

efindel

For odd dice questions, the rpg-create Yahoo group is a great place to ask -- Torben Mogenson, the author of the "Roll" language for expressing dice hangs out there, and often fields questions about dice probabilities.