The Forge Forums Read-only Archives
The live Forge Forums
|
Articles
|
Reviews
Welcome,
Guest
. Please
login
or
register
.
April 22, 2018, 09:24:19 PM
1 Hour
1 Day
1 Week
1 Month
Forever
Login with username, password and session length
Forum changes:
Editing of posts has been turned off until further notice.
Search:
Advanced search
275647
Posts in
27717
Topics by
4285
Members Latest Member:
-
Jason DAngelo
Most online today:
166
- most online ever:
429
(November 03, 2007, 04:35:43 AM)
The Forge Archives
Archive
GNS Model Discussion
Run-in with a Gamist Player
Pages:
1
[
2
]
« previous
next »
Author
Topic: Run-in with a Gamist Player (Read 8814 times)
Ron Edwards
Global Moderator
Member
Posts: 16490
Run-in with a Gamist Player
«
Reply #15 on:
October 24, 2001, 06:13:00 AM »
Hello,
Probably time to drop in here. If it's not clear from my essay, I do not agree with Brian's interpretation of Gamism by a wide margin. Citing the differences between our views does not constitute an argument.
By my definition, his descriptions of play (and certainly his game design) do not qualify as Gamism. By my view, the concept of "challenging oneself" applies as a goal across all of role-playing, being no more nor less than a particular take on Exploration.
The only reason posed to refute this view is that he prefers to think of himself as a Gamist and is aggravated that my definitions do not permit him to do so.
Whether the shoe fits Brian is irrelevant to me. What matters to me is whether the shoe is a fair, accurate, and useful construct. I have built it based on my years of observation and experience - people often enjoy role-playing in the manner described, according to the parameters listed. That goal is distinctive enough to have its own name, and in this case, it seems that I and the original Threefold are not deviating in any meaningful way.
One last note: if there is any one phrase I am weary of having thrown in my face, it is the "Ron admits that he doesn't understand Gamism" crap. I should like to announce that I understand Gamism fine, and enjoy it frequently.
Best,
Ron
Logged
contracycle
Member
Posts: 2807
Run-in with a Gamist Player
«
Reply #16 on:
October 24, 2001, 09:30:00 AM »
Well we seem to have descended to "more gamist than thou" argumentation.
Logged
Impeach the bomber boys:
www.impeachblair.org
www.impeachbush.org
"He who loves practice without theory is like the sailor who boards ship without a rudder and compass and never knows where he may cast."
- Leonardo da Vinci
Ron Edwards
Global Moderator
Member
Posts: 16490
Run-in with a Gamist Player
«
Reply #17 on:
October 24, 2001, 10:44:00 AM »
Gareth,
If that's how you see it, you're free to do so. I disagree with you. I do think that's how Brian has presented his case ("I'm a Gamist and your system describes me as a Simulationist, which must be wrong"), which is why I have never bothered to debate with him about it.
I, on the other hand, have defined my terms based on real human activity and placed them in a context that makes sense relative to other goals, and to role-playing as a whole. I have yet to hear an argument that challenges any aspect of the framework.
I am not claiming to know Gamism better than anyone else. I do disavow the commonly-repeated claim that I, being me, automatically know nothing about it.
Best,
Ron
Logged
Valamir
Member
Posts: 5574
Run-in with a Gamist Player
«
Reply #18 on:
October 24, 2001, 11:09:00 AM »
To differentiate "player skill" from "competition" is meaningless anyway. Brian raised many good points during his sojourn here, but I could never quite track how he managed to reach the conclusions he did based on the reasoning he used. I could go back and cite some instances that I found very hard to follow the segue but unfortuneately those posts are lost to posterity.
But essentially while I agree with much of what Brian said, one thing seemed very clear to me that obviously was not to him. I don't believe it is possible to talk about enjoying "player skill" without talking about competition. In order to see ones skill as a player lead to an enjoyable outcome one must have some means of measuring the application of that skill. What ever yard stick is used...thats competition.
I think perhaps alot of the whole "its competition, no its not" problem stems from people seeing competition only in the guise of a sporting event where people are struggling to defeat their fellow players. That is certainly one form of competition and it is certainly a viable form for Gamist roleplaying to take (both Hero Quest (which achieves a modest level of roleplaying in some variants) and Rune have a healthy dose of player vs. player and/or player vs. GM built into them).
However, other forms of competition are equally valid and the desire to exert player skill to effect the outcome of events in the game is certainly one of them.
In fact, I found Brians theories to be of tremendous use in attempting to differentiate between a Gamist player and a Simulationist player based on whether it was the players abilities or the character abilities that were focused on.
However, in the end...its still competition.
Logged
Ralph Mazza
Universalis: The Game of Unlimited Stories
James Holloway
Member
Posts: 372
Run-in with a Gamist Player
«
Reply #19 on:
October 25, 2001, 07:51:00 AM »
Quote
On 2001-10-24 15:09, Valamir wrote:
To differentiate "player skill" from "competition" is meaningless anyway.
In particular, remember that Brian stressed
objective
tests of player skill, which necessitates a yardstick of some kind (else whence the objectivity?) That, at least as far as I understand it, matches Ron's description of competition. I also agree that the problem is that competition as used on the Forge doesn't necessarily mean what most people think when they hear "competition"...
a problem with which I think we're all familiar.
Logged
Valamir
Member
Posts: 5574
Run-in with a Gamist Player
«
Reply #20 on:
October 25, 2001, 08:17:00 AM »
Quote
I also agree that the problem is that competition as used on the Forge doesn't necessarily mean what most people think when they hear "competition"...
a problem with which I think we're all familiar.
Oh...I could rant for days about that problem...no wait...I already have :smile:
I've pretty much resigned myself to mentally adding As Defined Here after all Jargon words people use...even as I cringe at the damage that it does to broader acceptability.
Logged
Ralph Mazza
Universalis: The Game of Unlimited Stories
contracycle
Member
Posts: 2807
Run-in with a Gamist Player
«
Reply #21 on:
October 25, 2001, 08:25:00 AM »
Well, I think this is because there is no necessary link between an "objective test of player skill" and "competition". As has been pointed out, there need to be yardsticks, but these may well be self-imposed. The problem with the concept of competition conceptually is that it is then taken too far, and gamism becomes defined as competition BETWEEN players, which I think it manifestly is not.
Logged
Impeach the bomber boys:
www.impeachblair.org
www.impeachbush.org
"He who loves practice without theory is like the sailor who boards ship without a rudder and compass and never knows where he may cast."
- Leonardo da Vinci
contracycle
Member
Posts: 2807
Run-in with a Gamist Player
«
Reply #22 on:
October 25, 2001, 08:29:00 AM »
Well, I think this is because there is no necessary link between an "objective test of player skill" and "competition". As has been pointed out, there need to be yardsticks, but these may well be self-imposed. The problem with the concept of competition conceptually is that it is then taken too far, and gamism becomes defined as competition BETWEEN players, which I think it manifestly is not.
Logged
Impeach the bomber boys:
www.impeachblair.org
www.impeachbush.org
"He who loves practice without theory is like the sailor who boards ship without a rudder and compass and never knows where he may cast."
- Leonardo da Vinci
Ron Edwards
Global Moderator
Member
Posts: 16490
Run-in with a Gamist Player
«
Reply #23 on:
October 25, 2001, 09:01:00 AM »
Hello,
I have posted a long essay in the "Gamism and Premise" thread which addresses some of the posts in this thread as well.
Best,
Ron
Logged
Valamir
Member
Posts: 5574
Run-in with a Gamist Player
«
Reply #24 on:
October 25, 2001, 10:37:00 AM »
Quote
On 2001-10-25 12:25, contracycle wrote:
Well, I think this is because there is no necessary link between an "objective test of player skill" and "competition".
Well I would at this point have to unequivicably 100% state "you are wrong". They are irrefuteably and inevitably linked. Measuring oneself, ones accomplishments, ones abilities, etc against any form of yard stick is a competitive act. Period.
I'm thinking that you have some personal ill will towards the term or idea of competition and at this point you are just flailing against having to see that term referring to something that you otherwise relate to.
Quote
As has been pointed out, there need to be yardsticks, but these may well be self-imposed.
Doesn't matter.
In the words of that old Survivor song from Rocky IV
"Its you against you. Its the paradox that drives us all"
Whether the yardstick you are competing against is external or internal, you are still competeing against it.
Quote
The problem with the concept of competition conceptually is that it is then taken too far, and gamism becomes defined as competition BETWEEN players, which I think it manifestly is not.
Whose taking it that far? Maybe that retard reporter in Brazil who recently described a girl's death as being related to Roleplaying which are games where people pretend to kill each other with dice. But certainly no one here at the Forge.
Logged
Ralph Mazza
Universalis: The Game of Unlimited Stories
contracycle
Member
Posts: 2807
Run-in with a Gamist Player
«
Reply #25 on:
October 29, 2001, 04:45:00 AM »
Quote
Well I would at this point have to unequivicably 100% state "you are wrong". They are irrefuteably and inevitably linked. Measuring oneself, ones accomplishments, ones abilities, etc against any form of yard stick is a competitive act. Period.
Quote
I'm thinking that you have some personal ill will towards the term or idea of competition and at this point you are just flailing against having to see that term referring to something that you otherwise relate to.
And I think that yopu are so obsessed by the concept that you apply it in circumstances for which it is manifestly innapropriate.
Quote
Whether the yardstick you are competing against is external or internal, you are still competeing against it.
An entirely sense-less statement
Quote
Whose taking it that far? Maybe that retard reporter in Brazil who recently described a girl's death as being related to Roleplaying which are games where people pretend to kill each other with dice. But certainly no one here at the Forge.
Logged
Impeach the bomber boys:
www.impeachblair.org
www.impeachbush.org
"He who loves practice without theory is like the sailor who boards ship without a rudder and compass and never knows where he may cast."
- Leonardo da Vinci
Pages:
1
[
2
]
« previous
next »
Jump to:
Please select a destination:
-----------------------------
Welcome to the Archives
-----------------------------
=> Welcome to the Archives
-----------------------------
General Forge Forums
-----------------------------
=> First Thoughts
=> Playtesting
=> Endeavor
=> Actual Play
=> Publishing
=> Connections
=> Conventions
=> Site Discussion
-----------------------------
Archive
-----------------------------
=> RPG Theory
=> GNS Model Discussion
=> Indie Game Design
-----------------------------
Independent Game Forums
-----------------------------
=> Adept Press
=> Arkenstone Publishing
=> Beyond the Wire Productions
=> Black and Green Games
=> Bully Pulpit Games
=> Dark Omen Games
=> Dog Eared Designs
=> Eric J. Boyd Designs
=> Errant Knight Games
=> Galileo Games
=> glyphpress
=> Green Fairy Games
=> Half Meme Press
=> Incarnadine Press
=> lumpley games
=> Muse of Fire Games
=> ndp design
=> Night Sky Games
=> one.seven design
=> Robert Bohl Games
=> Stone Baby Games
=> These Are Our Games
=> Twisted Confessions
=> Universalis
=> Wild Hunt Studios
-----------------------------
Inactive Forums
-----------------------------
=> My Life With Master Playtest
=> Adamant Entertainment
=> Bob Goat Press
=> Burning Wheel
=> Cartoon Action Hour
=> Chimera Creative
=> CRN Games
=> Destroy All Games
=> Evilhat Productions
=> HeroQuest
=> Key 20 Publishing
=> Memento-Mori Theatricks
=> Mystic Ages Online
=> Orbit
=> Scattershot
=> Seraphim Guard
=> Wicked Press
=> Review Discussion
=> XIG Games
=> SimplePhrase Press
=> The Riddle of Steel
=> Random Order Creations
=> Forge Birthday Forum