The Forge Reference Project

 

Topic: Narrativism and Fortune mechanics
Started by: taalyn
Started on: 3/26/2004
Board: GNS Model Discussion


On 3/26/2004 at 3:01pm, taalyn wrote:
Narrativism and Fortune mechanics

Generally, games specifically for Narr playing see to have these few specific characteristics:

- no GM, i.e. collaborative
- resource management for conflict resolution
- conflict resolution is usually between players, not characters
- no exclusive player "ownership" of a character

Not all Narr games have those, but a good number that I've seen do, anyway.

So my question is this - are there any games that have a narr-supporting focus, but use Fortune mechanics to do so? Can you have collaborative storytelling and use Fortune mechanics (instead of Karma or Drama)?

I stumbled across Jonathan Walton's Humble Mythologies (incredibly brilliant), and this seemed like it would work, with the right kind of Fortune mechanic. That's why I'm asking. In particular, it seems like a Fortune system using the Elements (or an additional set of Elements) would be perfect.

Aidan

Message 10407#109701

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by taalyn
...in which taalyn participated
...in GNS Model Discussion
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 3/26/2004




On 3/26/2004 at 3:07pm, xiombarg wrote:
RE: Narrativism and Fortune mechanics

Perhaps I'm misreading what you mean by "Narr", but Sorcerer is generally considered Narrativist and it uses a GM and dice. Ditto Trollbabe, tho that's "vanilla Narrativist" which is a sort of different thing.

Message 10407#109702

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by xiombarg
...in which xiombarg participated
...in GNS Model Discussion
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 3/26/2004




On 3/26/2004 at 3:21pm, Michael S. Miller wrote:
RE: Narrativism and Fortune mechanics

I think your points only accurately describe Universalis. Other Narr games to look at are My Life with Master, The Riddle of Steel, Orkworld, heck, there's a bunch on a chart in the narrativism essay, and I think Universalis is the only one that does what you describe. Are we sure we're talking about the same thing?

Message 10407#109707

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Michael S. Miller
...in which Michael S. Miller participated
...in GNS Model Discussion
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 3/26/2004




On 3/26/2004 at 3:33pm, taalyn wrote:
RE: Narrativism and Fortune mechanics

You guys are right. I'll go read the Narrativism article again.

That said, there's a certain kind of Narr game (which Humble Mythologies looks like), and I haven't seen any of them that use Fortune mechanics. That's what I'm asking about. Universalis is one of them, but I've seen others.

I guess I'm saying "hold on, let me read and clarify what I'm thinking about".

Message 10407#109710

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by taalyn
...in which taalyn participated
...in GNS Model Discussion
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 3/26/2004