The Forge Reference Project

 

Topic: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie
Started by: Peter Nordstrand
Started on: 4/4/2006
Board: Forge Birthday Forum


On 4/4/2006 at 9:27pm, Peter Nordstrand wrote:
Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

I'm going to tell you straight up: There is no "Nordic tradition", or whatever those Fins and that Norwegian guy Erik Flatsomething is talking about. I know, this is probably a big surprise to you, but it is true. The "Nordic Tradition" is just that thing that those Fins and that Norwegian guy Erik Flatsomething is talking about. Really? Yes. Really!

I am sure that whatever it is they are doing is fine and fulfilling and groundbreaking and whatever, but, well, I'm not part of it. Most of us are not.

Oh, and if you wonder why the Fins so emphatically keep saying that "it" isn't called Scandinavia, it is because they don't live in here. So now you know.

It feels good to get it off my chest.

Message 19337#202420

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Peter Nordstrand
...in which Peter Nordstrand participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/4/2006




On 4/4/2006 at 9:40pm, Peter Nordstrand wrote:
Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

Flatnose, is it?

Message 19337#202435

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Peter Nordstrand
...in which Peter Nordstrand participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/4/2006




On 4/4/2006 at 9:49pm, rafial wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

Would that be any relation to Flat Eric?

Message 19337#202440

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by rafial
...in which rafial participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/4/2006




On 4/4/2006 at 9:56pm, Peter Nordstrand wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

They could be one and the same, for all I know. I don't know these Nordic Tradition people. Actually, I think they were all the brain child of Ralph Mazza, as part of some bizarre scheme simultaneously related to the US invasion of Iraq and meat-eating. That is all I can tell you, right now. Got to go put on my tinfoil cap.

Message 19337#202441

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Peter Nordstrand
...in which Peter Nordstrand participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/4/2006




On 4/4/2006 at 10:32pm, Bryan Hansel wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

Well, of course, the Nordic Tradition is a lie.  Here in Minnesota, we invented it to draw tourists to our very own Kensington Rune Stone. (http://farshores.org/avikston.htm)  And so we could name our football team the Vikings.  And it gave us the permission to say, "You bettcha."

Message 19337#202460

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Bryan Hansel
...in which Bryan Hansel participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/4/2006




On 4/4/2006 at 11:05pm, Peter Nordstrand wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

Roleplaying draws tourists to Minnesota? That's bizarre.

;-)

Message 19337#202477

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Peter Nordstrand
...in which Peter Nordstrand participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/4/2006




On 4/4/2006 at 11:17pm, Shreyas Sampat wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

Man, I was sure that thing was a hoax.

Message 19337#202486

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Shreyas Sampat
...in which Shreyas Sampat participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/4/2006




On 4/5/2006 at 1:34am, c wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

Minnesota? It is a hoax. No such place.

Message 19337#202541

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by c
...in which c participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/5/2006




On 4/5/2006 at 1:51am, Valamir wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

The Nordic Tradition is all part of my secret plot to take over the world with a cult of free forming viking Larpists based in Minnesota who eat only bacon.  But you can't blame me for Iraq, that was all Dubya's idea, he wanted a war and couldn't spell South Korea...me, I was pushing for France.

mmmm....bacon.

Message 19337#202549

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Valamir
...in which Valamir participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/5/2006




On 4/5/2006 at 3:35am, greyorm wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

Clyde wrote: Minnesota? It is a hoax. No such place.

Oh shit. They KNOW.

Message 19337#202604

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by greyorm
...in which greyorm participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/5/2006




On 4/5/2006 at 5:57am, Miskatonic wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

I'm totally one of those people who every time I see the Vikings logo, thinks "Hey! Vikings didn't have horns!" But what can you do?

My late grandfather owned a cap with stuffed horns sewn on. The front read "Horny Norsk." He seemed to think this was a hoot, which was disturbing seeing as it was, you know, my grandfather. Oddly, this was my German grandfather, not the Norwegian one.

If it is necessary for me to consume more bacon for Ralph, than so be it.

Message 19337#202634

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Miskatonic
...in which Miskatonic participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/5/2006




On 4/5/2006 at 6:03am, Peter Nordstrand wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

Hm ... why did I derail this? My first post is actually entirely true. Well, except that I do know Eirik Flathead's real name.

Message 19337#202638

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Peter Nordstrand
...in which Peter Nordstrand participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/5/2006




On 4/5/2006 at 6:27am, J. Tuomas Harviainen wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

And Peter is of course actually correct. Just like it's been said before, the experientialists are only a small, if influential minority (or a small, if influential figment of imagination) in the Nordic area (or was it Minnesota). And there are lots of fans of the "plain fun" school of thought who want nothing to do with the few hundred people into the experientialist scene.

As we all know, it's really just a celebrity cult. The most visible innovators just happen to be from those circles, and are good at presenting themselves as important. And it's called Nordic only because that's a convenient label. It isn't really like anything actually interesting, important or international as far as role-playing is concerned ever happens here. We're just insignificant art-dreamers with delusions of grandeur and too much time.

Message 19337#202645

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by J. Tuomas Harviainen
...in which J. Tuomas Harviainen participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/5/2006




On 4/5/2006 at 6:30am, Ben Lehman wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

Hey, Tuomas.  What happened with your paper thing?  Can I talk about it now?

Message 19337#202647

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Ben Lehman
...in which Ben Lehman participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/5/2006




On 4/5/2006 at 6:42am, talysman wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

J. wrote:
And there are lots of fans of the "plain fun" school of thought


Why did I wackyparse this as "plain fur"?

Message 19337#202653

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by talysman
...in which talysman participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/5/2006




On 4/5/2006 at 7:07am, Peter Nordstrand wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

Aha! There it is again, but in a different form. So the Nordic tradition people are the avant garde theory experimentalist thinkers and the rest of us are not reflecting at all, because we just want to have fun?

Well, okay. Which is it: Am I not Nordic or am I a "fan of the 'plain fun' school"? Seriously, if these are the only two alternatives, which one applies to me?

Oh, and I mean all of the above in the friendliest possible way.

Cheers,

/Peter

Message 19337#202659

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Peter Nordstrand
...in which Peter Nordstrand participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/5/2006




On 4/5/2006 at 7:13am, Miskatonic wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

Peter wrote:
Hm ... why did I derail this? My first post is actually entirely true. Well, except that I do know Eirik Flathead's real name.


Hmm. Well, I'm actually completely in the dark about whatever "controversy" you were talking about in the first place, so I presumed you were being silly. Out of any context, it does sound silly.

Message 19337#202661

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Miskatonic
...in which Miskatonic participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/5/2006




On 4/5/2006 at 7:15am, Peter Nordstrand wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

Oh. There is no controversy. Or at least there wasn't one until I created it in this very thread. :-)

And yeah, it is kind of silly.

Cheers,

/Peter

Message 19337#202663

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Peter Nordstrand
...in which Peter Nordstrand participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/5/2006




On 4/5/2006 at 7:17am, J. Tuomas Harviainen wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

Ben wrote:
Hey, Tuomas.  What happened with your paper thing?  Can I talk about it now?


Yes you can. It got what it deserved, i.e. heavy criticism based on questions of reliability and word formulation. I'll revise it eventually, run a few result confirmation experiments and try get it published on some peer-reviewed forum. But feel free to talk about it already. It's public now.

By the way, the seminar was excellent.

Message 19337#202664

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by J. Tuomas Harviainen
...in which J. Tuomas Harviainen participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/5/2006




On 4/5/2006 at 7:22am, J. Tuomas Harviainen wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

Peter wrote:
Well, okay. Which is it: Am I not Nordic or am I a "fan of the 'plain fun' school"? Seriously, if these are the only two alternatives, which one applies to me?


You are of course a Nordic who likes his games less avant-garde than the more vocal guys do. Honestly, the only reason it's called "Nordic style/tradition/etc." is because the damn Americans find that definition convenient. Any player from the Nordic area knows what the scene over here is actually like. Liking games "for fun" isn't a denial of reflection, just a different reflective focus.

Message 19337#202666

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by J. Tuomas Harviainen
...in which J. Tuomas Harviainen participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/5/2006




On 4/5/2006 at 7:35am, Peter Nordstrand wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

Hi again,

You are being very courteous, Toumas, which I appreciate.

Actually, the (admittedly silly, because it doesn't really matter) problem I have is just that you are speaking for me. I don't like avant garde? You don't know that. I play just "for fun"? Did I say that? No I didn't. You did. In fact, your kind of avant garde experimental theory making is not the only one. There are many ways, even in our little corner of the world, right?

Nuff said.

Have fun at Barnens ö.

All the best,

/Peter

Message 19337#202668

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Peter Nordstrand
...in which Peter Nordstrand participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/5/2006




On 4/5/2006 at 8:17am, J. Tuomas Harviainen wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

Peter wrote: Actually, the (admittedly silly, because it doesn't really matter) problem I have is just that you are speaking for me. I don't like avant garde? You don't know that. I play just "for fun"? Did I say that? No I didn't. You did. In fact, your kind of avant garde experimental theory making is not the only one. There are many ways, even in our little corner of the world, right?


I'll flog the dead horse a bit more: in contrast to what many people on rpg fora may believe, the so-called "Nordic" style has mostly been about openness to new ideas and the willingness to question conventions of play and game design, not about being avant-garde for its own sake. (Nor is it about beloging in a certain group.) Thus if you're doing experimentation for the sake of seeing what can actually be done using role-playing and telling others about it, you're actually following the supposedly "Nordic" ideals. But, if you're doing experimentation (or being avant-garde) but not spreading the knowledge, it's still gaming for fun. Just more advanced fun. (Which, if it must be said out loud, I do not consider any less worthy or important. For each their own style of play.)

(And what's wrong with you Swedes? You all misspell my name. Always. Why is it so hard to see that it's just a Thomas with a "u" instead of "h"?)

Thank you, I intend to have a great time at Barnens ö. Hopefully I'll also manage to interview a lot of people for my upcoming research project.

Message 19337#202681

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by J. Tuomas Harviainen
...in which J. Tuomas Harviainen participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/5/2006




On 4/5/2006 at 8:24am, matthijs wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

I'm all against the Nordic tradition. But I find myself doing more and more of the Nordic stuff. Experimenting with shared hypnotic fiction, participating in an undie LARP*, and trying to break the borders between LARP and tabletop.

It's a granfalloon.

* An undie LARP != an indie LARP. Undie LARPS are when you play in your underwear.

Message 19337#202685

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by matthijs
...in which matthijs participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/5/2006




On 4/5/2006 at 9:42am, Merten wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

Peter wrote: I am sure that whatever it is they are doing is fine and fulfilling and groundbreaking and whatever, but, well, I'm not part of it. Most of us are not.


Actually, we're not doing anything. The last time we roleplayed was when Aftermath was all new and shiny. After that, we've just talked about playing. But one of these days, we will be playing. We'll do it with Aftermath. And we'll have a giant sheet with an unbelieveably large flowchart of EVERYTHING.

Aftermath. Gotta love it.

Message 19337#202697

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Merten
...in which Merten participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/5/2006




On 4/5/2006 at 10:20am, Thunder_God wrote:
RE: Re: Breaking News: The Nordic Tradition is a Lie

Valamir wrote:
The Nordic Tradition is all part of my secret plot to take over the world with a cult of free forming viking Larpists based in Minnesota who eat only bacon.  But you can't blame me for Iraq, that was all Dubya's idea, he wanted a war and couldn't spell South Korea...me, I was pushing for France.


Watch his eyes as he lies! We who are not of American descent all know that there is no such place as "France"! You only use it to rally support amongst your constituency!

You'll have to try again and do better Mr. Mazza!

Message 19337#202710

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Thunder_God
...in which Thunder_God participated
...in Forge Birthday Forum
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/5/2006