The Forge Reference Project

 

Topic: [TSoY] BDTP Questions
Started by: Belinda K.
Started on: 4/24/2006
Board: CRN Games


On 4/24/2006 at 1:43am, Belinda K. wrote:
[TSoY] BDTP Questions

I'm stuck on some of the wording...

After the free-and-clear stage, everyone rolls ability checks for their action. If this is the first action in Bringing Down the Pain, the winner at the roll that initiated Bringing Down the Pain gets bonus dice to her first action equal to the difference between her and her opponent's success levels.

Before BDTP:  Player A loses to player B in a combat situation by an SL of 1.  Player A declares BDTP.
First Round BDTP: Player B gets a +1 bonus die because Player A lost the conflict in the previous non-round. Is this correct?

If the actions are parallel, both sides take harm equal to their attacker's success level.

Does 'both sides' refer to both attacker and defender? If Player A is cooking yams and Player B is tuning her harp and both are in BDTP against each other in a conflict, does it mean that even if Player A wins, both he and Player B take the same amount of damage each time? If so, how can there be a winner if both are damaged at the same rate?

If one action is defensive, and that player wins, she gets bonus dice to her next action equal to the difference between the success levels.

So only in defensive situations, does the winner of the previous round get bonus dice equal to their victory in SL from the previous round? And the loser takes Harm damage in SL levels?

What if both players are attacking each other at once? It would be a perpendicular action, but not defensive, so is true that Player A gets no bonus dice on the next round if they win, but difference-in-SL-damage is still dealt? So it's more strategic to defend against your opponent until they either get 'broken' or give up?

Message 19603#205558

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Belinda K.
...in which Belinda K. participated
...in CRN Games
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/24/2006




On 4/24/2006 at 2:38am, rafial wrote:
Re: [TSoY] BDTP Questions


Before BDTP:  Player A loses to player B in a combat situation by an SL of 1.  Player A declares BDTP.
First Round BDTP: Player B gets a +1 bonus die because Player A lost the conflict in the previous non-round. Is this correct?


Pretty much... Let's clarify.  Before BDTP,  player A rolls, and gets SL1.  Player B rolls and gets SL2.  If BDTP is now declared player B will get 1 bonus die, caclucated as winning SL2 - losing SL1 = 1.

If so, how can there be a winner if both are damaged at the same rate?


For parallel actions:

Player A makes her cooking roll (let's say SL3) -> Player B takes 3 Harm.
Player B makes her harp tuning roll (let's say SL1) -> Player A takes 1 Harm.

So only in defensive situations, does the winner of the previous round get bonus dice equal to their victory in SL from the previous round?


Yes.

And the loser takes Harm damage in SL levels?


No, the definition of a defensive action is that even the person taken that action wins, no harm is done.

So lets say Alice is trying to hit Bob with a sword, and Bob is dodging (defensive action).

If Alice rolls SL3 and Bob rolls SL2, Bob takes 1 Harm (SL3 - SL2).

If Bob rolls SL3 and Bob rolls SL1, Alice takes NO Harm (because Bob's action was defensive).  On the NEXT round of action, Bob will get 2 bonus dice.

Caveat: this is all my personal undertanding, and does not claim to be official ;)

Message 19603#205560

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by rafial
...in which rafial participated
...in CRN Games
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/24/2006




On 4/24/2006 at 4:19am, demiurgeastaroth wrote:
RE: Re: [TSoY] BDTP Questions

Just to clarify that last bit, what Rafial meant was:

rafial wrote:
So lets say Alice is trying to hit Bob with a sword, and Bob is dodging (defensive action).

If Alice rolls SL3 and Bob rolls SL2, Bob takes 1 Harm (SL3 - SL2).

If Bob rolls SL3 and Alice rolls SL1, Alice takes NO Harm (because Bob's action was defensive).  On the NEXT round of action, Bob will get 2 bonus dice.

Message 19603#205563

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by demiurgeastaroth
...in which demiurgeastaroth participated
...in CRN Games
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/24/2006




On 4/24/2006 at 8:43am, rafial wrote:
RE: Re: [TSoY] BDTP Questions

Ah yes, thanks Darren.  The embarrassing thing is, I read over my post looking for that kind of mistake and STILL missed it :P

Message 19603#205567

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by rafial
...in which rafial participated
...in CRN Games
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/24/2006




On 4/24/2006 at 10:04am, demiurgeastaroth wrote:
RE: Re: [TSoY] BDTP Questions

It's always easier to spot things like that in other people's posts, isn't it? (I know from painful experience!)

Message 19603#205570

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by demiurgeastaroth
...in which demiurgeastaroth participated
...in CRN Games
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/24/2006




On 4/24/2006 at 11:57am, Belinda K. wrote:
RE: Re: [TSoY] BDTP Questions

Thanks - I think I've got it now.

Message 19603#205573

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Belinda K.
...in which Belinda K. participated
...in CRN Games
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 4/24/2006