The Forge Reference Project

 

Topic: Giving in DitV
Started by: Gaerik
Started on: 5/23/2007
Board: lumpley games


On 5/23/2007 at 4:43pm, Gaerik wrote:
Giving in DitV

There are a couple of threads in Actual Play concerning DitV and one of them is discussing Giving during a conflict and the conversation there is making me think that I'm playing incorrectly.  Here's my understanding of Giving...

GM:  (raising)  Jeb takes his gun out and shoots you in the face.
Me:  I don't want to take it that far.  I give.

The result is that Jeb didn't shoot me in the face and I don't take Fallout from it.  Giving cancels out the Raise that I gave in to.

The other thread seems to be saying that Giving means I still get shot in the face, there just aren't any mechanical consequences to it (ie. I don't take Fallout.)

Which is correct and is there a page number in the book that I can refer to?

Message 23966#234685

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Gaerik
...in which Gaerik participated
...in lumpley games
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 5/23/2007




On 5/23/2007 at 9:08pm, lumpley wrote:
Re: Giving in DitV

Either. As the giver it's your choice which, case by case.

Here's what I've said about it before, very slightly edited:

lumpley wrote:
When you give, you're entitled to say how your character gives - that is, what your character does with the outstanding raise - and you don't take fallout. Those are the rules.

In play, you'll find that the fictional events have momentum. Since the outcome is the same either way - your character stops swearing (for example) and you take no fallout - sometimes you'll choose to go along with the final raise, sometimes you'll choose to block or dodge it. There's no rule about which you must choose under what circumstances.


-Vincent

Message 23966#234696

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by lumpley
...in which lumpley participated
...in lumpley games
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 5/23/2007




On 5/24/2007 at 12:25am, Eliarhiman6 wrote:
RE: Re: Giving in DitV

Just as a precisation: I play like this for EVERY block of a raise. The player who block can say how much of the stated raise happened, keeping in consideration the narrative continuity of the actions.  It's correct?

Message 23966#234709

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Eliarhiman6
...in which Eliarhiman6 participated
...in lumpley games
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 5/24/2007




On 5/24/2007 at 1:07am, Gaerik wrote:
RE: Re: Giving in DitV

Okay.  I think I've got it.  If you Give you can decide to Block or Dodge the last Raise or you can just roll with it.  Regardless, Fallout is avoided.

Message 23966#234713

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Gaerik
...in which Gaerik participated
...in lumpley games
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 5/24/2007




On 5/24/2007 at 2:36pm, lumpley wrote:
RE: Re: Giving in DitV

Moreno: yes. Good point.

-Vincent

Message 23966#234755

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by lumpley
...in which lumpley participated
...in lumpley games
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 5/24/2007