Topic: [Ill Fated]
Started by: Teplin
Started on: 11/18/2008
Board: First Thoughts
On 11/18/2008 at 10:38pm, Teplin wrote:
[Ill Fated]
I finished my first rpg. It's a psychological horror story game. I don't have any specific questions, I just want to see what people think of it, and if it's understandable as written.
http://docs.google.com/View?docid=df8mpz7p_0c2ktprgv
On 11/20/2008 at 4:27pm, Ron Edwards wrote:
Re: [Ill Fated]
Hello,
The one thing I don't understand is whether I, as a player, actually make any choices of any kind. At least on my first reading, I see that I get to act things out as directed by various rules, but that's all. Is that what the point of play is for this game, to act out what's happening?
Best, Ron
On 11/20/2008 at 8:45pm, Teplin wrote:
RE: Re: [Ill Fated]
Ron wrote:
Hello,
The one thing I don't understand is whether I, as a player, actually make any choices of any kind. At least on my first reading, I see that I get to act things out as directed by various rules, but that's all. Is that what the point of play is for this game, to act out what's happening?
Best, Ron
That's basically correct, except that I'd say the point of play is to create what's happening. The mechanics tell you, generally, how things turn out, but now what happens to make them turn out that way. A storytelling game in the most literal sense of the term, the goal is to create the story. I thought that it might work because the powerlessness of the characters is a major theme, but I can definitely understand if it's a deal breaker for a lot of people. The thing is, I'm not sure how I'd fix it without breaking the rest of the game.