The Forge Reference Project

 

Topic: [SS/TWoN] Mind control
Started by: Paolo D.
Started on: 8/8/2010
Board: Arkenstone Publishing


On 8/8/2010 at 1:26pm, Paolo D. wrote:
[SS/TWoN] Mind control

Ok, here's my question of the day :-)

How do we should handle mind control in stakes?

...for example, in TWoN the Three-Corner magic has the Enthrallment ability to "force another being to bend his will".
But a stake about "charming/dominating my opponent" is't too much? It sounds me like having death in the stake.

But maybe this is because I haven't ever seen this in action... In your actual play, how does it worked?

Message 30129#278343

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Paolo D.
...in which Paolo D. participated
...in Arkenstone Publishing
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 8/8/2010




On 8/8/2010 at 1:50pm, Eero Tuovinen wrote:
Re: [SS/TWoN] Mind control

Yes, I agree with you that Enthrallment is rather high stakes, not unlike death caused by Destruction. The focus can be used for less severe stakes than total mind control, though. For example, "Convince him to speak to me." is perfectly valid, it doesn't have to be about total mind slavery every time.

Note that technically, the way I play, you can put death into stakes as a character's intent. It's just that the stakes get modified by propriety: "I want to kill him" becomes "We'll roll dice to see if he falls into the waterfall and out of this immediate story, reserving however the SG option to bring him back." Of course that latter is not said aloud in practice because we've already gone through the campaign propriety guidelines earlier - the players know that when we agree to "I kill him dead" stakes we really mean "Insofar as my character knows, he'll end up dead."

The above works for mental domination as well insofar as the group decides that this is a case of propriety - that is, they have to decide whether indefinite mind slavery fits into the stylings of TSoY. When I play a simple conflict stake of mind-slavery gets executed with the understanding that it's a temporary condition that might break whenever the victim gathers his resolve for a Resist check - usually at a dramatic moment. Accomplishing something like completely and irreversibly breaking another's mind is handled exactly like death - you might think that you succeeded, but they always have some inner reserves they might draw on when the moment is right to surprise us all with the tenaciousness of human nature. An extended conflict could be used to cause real, total mind-death, of course. And non-named NPCs, those often get handled with less jurisprudence, allowing the evil mind-fucker to break them with just as little compunction as that afforded to minor NPCs when a sword-wielding murderer comes calling.

Three-Corner magic is also temporary, so it's not very good for truly breaking a person. I'd probably use alchemy for ruining lives in this manner as a first pick.

Message 30129#278344

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Eero Tuovinen
...in which Eero Tuovinen participated
...in Arkenstone Publishing
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 8/8/2010




On 8/9/2010 at 12:12pm, Paolo D. wrote:
RE: Re: [SS/TWoN] Mind control

Ok, great! That's exactly what I needed.

Thanks a lot! :-)

Message 30129#278355

Previous & subsequent topics...
...started by Paolo D.
...in which Paolo D. participated
...in Arkenstone Publishing
...including keyword:

 (leave blank for none)
...from around 8/9/2010