Topic: My RPG Review
Started by: Morfedel
Started on: 6/3/2003
Board: The Riddle of Steel
On 6/3/2003 at 12:30pm, Morfedel wrote:
My RPG Review
Ok, my review is up on RPG.NET.
It wasn't overly positive, and in one area I may have been a bit too harsh, but don't flame me, because overall I gave it positive marks! :)
http://www.rpg.net/reviews/archive/9/9361.phtml
On 6/3/2003 at 9:07pm, Brian Leybourne wrote:
RE: My RPG Review
On the whole it's not a bad review at all, there's certainly no need to apologise for it.
Although my pet peeve (since you like that term so much) is writing a review and not spell/grammar checking it before submission. Made it very painful to read at times.
However, all press is good press as they say. Well done.
Brian.
On 6/3/2003 at 9:29pm, Morfedel wrote:
RE: My RPG Review
Odd; I didn't spell/grammer check it, but that's because, generally, my spelling and grammer is very good. Not perfect, but very good. I have an english minor, and have done some professional writing as well.
As such, it shouldn't have been THAT bad; granted, I wrote it before heading to bed, was tired, and was in a rush, but still, it shouldn't have been so bad as to make it hard to read?!
The only thing I know I did was that I have this bad tendency to leave out apostrophes, typing dont instead of don't, for instance, but still....
I'll have to go back and look at it. All in all, I find your comment very disturbing that I may have written a piece rife with spelling / grammar flaws.
Other than that, though, yes; I was careful to say that the items in question were pet peeves, and not flaws in the system, because I know in some cases people would not care, or even disagree. I was attempting to be honest there. :)
*Spelling hard enough to make it hard to read? Damn, I need to look that over again....*
On 6/3/2003 at 9:47pm, Morfedel wrote:
RE: My RPG Review
Well, I did a spell check; taking out the words I intentionally misspell (slang, leaving out apostrophes, etc), I had 25 misspelled words.
Most of them were "particularly" or "proficiency". I knew how to spell those words, yet I ROUTINELY misspelled them in the review. What was up with that?
There were only three words that I misspelled, thinking them to be spelled correctly. The rest were my typing too fast and not double-checking, sigh....
On 6/3/2003 at 11:29pm, Brian Leybourne wrote:
RE: My RPG Review
Morfedel wrote: *Spelling hard enough to make it hard to read? Damn, I need to look that over again....*
I didn't say hard to read, I said painful to read.
And that's really only because I'm anally pedantic, so I wouldn't worry too much about it :-)
Brian.
On 6/4/2003 at 12:37pm, Morfedel wrote:
RE: My RPG Review
Better start spell-checking everything you type from now on, Spelling-Bee-Boy!
;)
heh
On 6/4/2003 at 8:01pm, Claymore wrote:
RE: My RPG Review
I thought the review was fair and addressed many of the concerns I have had as well. Good Job!
Claymore
On 6/4/2003 at 8:38pm, Brian Leybourne wrote:
RE: My RPG Review
Morfedel wrote: Better start spell-checking everything you type from now on, Spelling-Bee-Boy!
;)
heh
Eye doo, aynd mi spealling iz olways purfict. :-)
Brian.
On 6/4/2003 at 8:51pm, Morfedel wrote:
RE: My RPG Review
Gah! No! Not again!!!!1
*James falls over, his eyes bleeding....*
Oh, and thanks clay. :)
On 6/5/2003 at 3:41am, Noon wrote:
RE: My RPG Review
I still say don't sweat the small stuff! :)
On 6/5/2003 at 6:18am, prophet118 wrote:
RE: My RPG Review
dont worry bout brian, thats just how he is... hehe
"cheer up brian"
dont make me start singing... hehe
On 6/5/2003 at 7:37am, arxhon wrote:
RE: My RPG Review
As a fellow reviewer, i say "Well Done." :-)
I like how you were fair with your analysis on the game, rather than all "WooHoo! This game rules!" or "Blarg! TRoS Suxxors!"
Oh, Brian, you forgot an 'l' in spaelling.