OK, I am toying around with a strange sort of resolution mechanic and I am interested in the board's feedback on it. This is still firmly in the idea stage, I haven't tried implementing this in play. It completely eliminates the fortune aspect and focuses on character effort. I'm not sure if there are any games out there like this (Riddle of Steel's combat dice are similar, but not quite the same).

Each character has two pools determined by stats, a mental and a physical pool. These are pools of "tokens," for lack of a better term, which can be used to take actions in the game. The goal here is to simulate the allocation of physical/mental resources to any given situation.

Characters can take as many actions as they want in a resolution conflict (a fight, attempting to break something, hiding, etc.). Each action requires a minimum expenditure of one token. A minimum of one token must be spent to initiate an action (in other words, even if a straight stat/skill test would succeed, if the player doesn't allocate a token, the character doesn't even try). The player can choose to spend as many or few tokens as desired.

Success or failure is purely a threshold test--the character's basic ability (stats/skills) are compared numerically to a required target to overcome, and if the character exceeds the target, he succeeds. Each token applied adds to the stat/skill total when determining success. The rub is that the character cannot reallocate tokens in mid-action--if he is expending all physical tokens on some activity, and is suddenly attacked or the circumstances change, he has no further tokens to devote to the new factor. Sustained actions would occupy tokens for multiple conflicts.

Token allocation would also be subject to fatigue rules. If the player allocates a certain number of tokens to any effort, the character is fatigued and his token pool is diminished. The character can also be physically or mentally damaged, which would temporarily or permanently affect the token pools.

I can see many circumstances where both mental and physical faculties must be applied to succeed at a task. I haven't nailed down the interaction between the two pools, but I think that it would be easier to apply mental tokens to physical tasks than vice versa.

This is very similar to the new Marvel Universe RPG, which also uses token vs. a threshold of some sort. The difference is that your introduce stats as a numerical value for the comparison, modified by tokens, whereas for MURPG, the stats determine the token pools. I like.

I wonder if you might include a soul-like pool in there as well (for the happy mind/body/soul triangle). I would think that any pool can aid any other, though it might be easier to aid physical with soul than with mind, say on a two for one ratio, or something like that.

Aidan

Politically Incorrect Games' Active Exploits system of which the new Marvel Universe game is derived uses the methods you describe almost exactly. Since their Active Exploits game is free you might want to check it out.

The system seems pretty simple and able to quell the concerns of those who fear diceless games.

And, as a tiny plug for myself, there is always Success...