If someone could get me space layout and a few specifics (two story or not, arch/frame, open from howmany sides, ect.) I could build a booth that could be put up and taken down fairly easily. The problems are going to be transportation and cost.
I live in california. Transporting the booth across the country will be a problem.
Who's going to pay for the materials cost. Do I send someone a bill? Will there be a money pool to draw from? I'm willing to do the labor for free, but there will be other costs to consider
Also, If I build the booth to specific specs that means that we will need to have the same size booth every year. Is that realistic?
Storage? Where's the booth going to go for the rest of the year.
Hiya,
Jasper, you're talking about GenCon SoCal, right? If so, then the people to talk to are Clinton Nixon and Alexander Cherry.
It'd be great if this effort could be a rehearsal for construction ideas for next year in Indianapolis.
Best,
Ron
Actually, I was talking about Indie, for next year's con. That's the big one. I'm going to try to make it to SoCal, but it'll be by the skin of my teeth. There's no way I'd have enough time to build a booth and transport it before December. Calder and I are in a production of Romeo and Juliet right now and it's eating all our time.
So to clarify, I can build a booth for Indie, but only if I can get the information I need at least 3 months before the compleation deadline.
So here's the process I've outlined
Step 1: Send me the dimentions of the space we will have, including hight restrictions, and what type of booth it will be (end, corner, middle. ect.) Also give me a yes or no on the 2nd story option.
Step 2: Draft 1 and materials list with a proposed budget is sent to whoever has the final say
Step 3: Feedback/ Revision process and amending of budgetary problems
(a.k.a. Everyone argues about what they want and I let them know if it's realistic or not.)
Step 4: I draw out a second draft
Step 5: More arguing. Final concensus/ revision
Step 6: Final Draft
Step 7: Approval of governing bodies
Step 8: Construction
Step 9: Transportation and storage
As you can see, the process is very long, SoCal would be impossible. I need to be through to step 7 with at least 3 months to spare before the convention to make room for the inevitable hicups that always happen during construction. The ammount of time is based on my estimate of how much assistance I think I'll have (not much) and how much time a day I'll be able to spend on it.
Hi there,
I get it now. And thanks, Jasper, for spearheading this effort with enough lead time actually to get it done.
Trouble is, the booth dimensions for next year are completely up in the air. I do think the steps you've outlined are absolutely correct, so I suppose we can initiate a discussion about it.
You were there - what do you think? Remember, the core of the booth is actual play, with sales emerging from that. More than anything, we want an environment that says "Forge." As a member of that culture (remember our discussion at the Italian restaraunt?), you know what that should feel like - so what kind of physical space would work best for it?
Best,
Ron
As I understand it, there are two possibilities for both size next year -- 20x10 and 20x20. If this isn't right, please correct me, but it seemed that was the upshot of the recent conversations. I can't really see going down to 10x10, or going above 20x20, though if someone else can, I'd like to hear how that might come to pass.
So, hey, Jasper, guess what? More work for you! Yay! Why don't you give us two preliminary designs -- one for 20x20 and one for 20x10? (honestly, they don't necessarily have to be all that different.) Furthermore, go into the kitchen and make me a sandwich! And one for Ron! And stop complaining about having to lie dead on the stage for a long scene because you're playing Tybalt! And get Calder to run another session of Nocturne Imperium!
yrs--
--Ben
P.S. Having exhausted my supply of imperatives for the evening, I'd like to note that since Jasper and I are old friends, I get to talk shit to him, but none of the rest of you do.
Right, so here I go.
I think that 10x20 is enough, especially if we add the second story. 20x20 with a second story would create a cave-like ground floor that would deter customers. Open space is important.
So, what I'd like to see is an isle-end booth so that we could be open from three directions, just like the last one. The main diffrence would be the second story which would effectively triple play space.
The ground floor would have a 9 foot celing held aloft by four main corner posts and possably one central post. I'd like to stear clear of the center post (for the same reasons that the tower shelf was decided to be a bad idea) but it may not be possible. I'd like the 2nd floor to have a 2000 lb dispersed load bearing capacity. This may mean working in metal.
The four posts would also create the "framed" look that I talked about earlier. The 9 ft. celing would create the illusion of open space and lift the 2nd story to a point that it could be seen from nearly anywhere in the hall.
the 2nd story would be an open platform with a 3 1/2 ft. retaining bar or wall.
the stairs would be a switch back with one landing set in one of the far corners. This will increase stability, optimize space and create a handy storage space.
This basic design could work for nearly any spacing or placement possibilities.
the main difference between 10x20 and 20x20 will be support. Supporting a 20x20 celing/floor will require probably 4 interior posts to distribute weight.
I really need someone to find out if the 2nd story is an option.
Ben, your sandwich is in the mail.
I don't think that a central post is a bad idea as long as it can also be used as a display space. While I'm aware that some people weren't fond of Paul's awesome display shelf, it would fit perfectly around a support post (it is hollow in the center.) So a central post would not necessarily be a terrible idea.
I'm definitely with you about the cavelike atmosphere in the 20x20 dowstairs. I think that, if we end up with a 20x20 booth (because of, say, a lot of interest) we will probably want to consider a 20x10 "loft" structure as a second story rather than covering the entire booth area.
Okay. Here are some considerations:
1) Lighting. We are going to want a *lot* of light in the downstairs, and we're going to want it to be attractive light. Lamps (either covered table, standing, or hanging) might give a nice "coffeehouse" feel. If we get our 'game menu' together and some nice wooden panelling we could get a very cool "coffee house" sort of feel. In short, though, we need light, and we need lighting to work with our aesthetic, whatever that is.
1a) Lighting means electricity. This is not necessarily a bad thing, but it means that Greg Porter's car battery may not be enough. We might want to bring several, or look into other electricity solutions. It also means that, if we're going to have a lot of electricity, we can do computerized things with both demos and credit cards. What is the situation for internet access in the distributor's hall? Wireless?
Also, I think we should be working electrical access into our design plans. Last year's set up, which blocked off a whole area that only the computer guys could use, was not so good. Let's design for it this time.
2) Fat gamers. Some of the people at GenCon are going to be well in excess of 300 pounds. First of all, we need to understand that having them upstairs may be a structural hazard. Second of all, they probably won't want to climb stairs, and we're going to need to make the stairs wide enough for them. Either that, or we only seat them downstairs, which restricts somewhat what we can do upstairs.
3) Storage. Where?
4) Checkout. Also where?
5) Also, just as a note, the structure of the booth gives us a lot of banner space -- we can hang wide, short banners off of the second story railing. Let's keep that in mind, and be sure we bring a lot.
I have some thoughts about set up. These are just brainstorming.
A) Upstairs is pure gaming space, downstairs has a little bit of gaming space, display, checkout, and storage.
Advantages: Those who want to just buy can just buy.
Disadvantages: Actual play is less visible (I think.) Possible cluttered feel to the downstairs.
B) Downstairs is purely gaming / display. Upstairs is storage and checkout, with a little bit of gaming space.
Advantages: Play is easy to see, lack of commercial presence may make the downstairs space seem more comfortable.
Disadvantages: People have to walk upstairs to check out. Lack of commercial space downstairs.
C) Downstairs is a little bit of display, gaming and a checkout. Upstairs is just storage.
Advantages: Only booth staff need go upstairs. Play space is still prioritized.
Disadvantages: Upstairs space is underutilized.
Also, Jasper, we're going to have to discuss how we're going to get this stuff from California to Indianapolis. I assume that driving is the only way.
yrs--
--Ben
I don't have a whole lot of input as to whys and wherefors, but someone should really *really* check with local state ordinances as well as the group that runs the Indy trade center as to if it's legal to nine places. Also check with the Gen*Con crew - you may find by poring over the dealer's agreement that it's not allowed - or if it is, if you spring it on them, it'll almost certainly be illegal next year (Or they have to consider the possibility of big game companies competing by expanding up.).
I don't know about Indiana, but I know if you tried to do this in Alberta, CA, you'd be breaking at least a couple laws/local ordinances. Like the rather esotaric one requiring *anyone* on a temporary openwork structure in excess of 6 feet to be wearing a fall protection harness and trained in its use.
I'd really recommend looking into that kind of "whaddya mean we can't put it up without a journeyman scaffolder on hand?"* kind of problem before you spend money/time/effort on it.
James
*Not a law hereabouts, but it is mandatory at some of the industrial sites I've worked at for a journeyman scaffolder to be in charge of any erection or disassembly of a temporary multilevel openwork structure (aka: scaffold).
Quote from: Jasper the MimboBen, your sandwich is in the mail.
Mmm... tasty.
Agree with above- I love the idea of expanding upwards, but after thinking about it a minute, and the Fat Gamers thing, and the possibility that, if something goes wrong, then all this timber and flesh tumble onto some brilliant designers and... well... the hobby couldn't cope with that loss :-)
Plus, the instant some Big Booth sees you doing that, they'll start waving and pointing fingers to management to see if it's allowed, and even if it otherwise would be, I'm still betting that they'll find a loophole... not to be a naysayer or anything, but it's just a LOT of work to build a sturdy and functional second story, only to have it smacked down by The Law.
However, having said that, I DO believe that the Third Dimension CAN be used. However, I'm thinking more of a long, flat platform raised high that:
1) You can hang banners or posters from, or color copies of the covers of all the books that are sold there, etc.
2) Better yet, can be used as a storage platform to house all the merchandise that isnt on the shelves, which can be retreived by a simple footstool. That way, it frees up all those tables underneath that we used as displays and "merchandise storage covers" (we can organize displays in a more efficient manner which allows for more gaming tables).
3) I think the best way we can attract more people to the booth next year is to create a Romance RPG of a few pages, maybe even using Paul's girlfriend's design as a base. Next, we make a color cover design for that game. Finally, we make 2 8x10 foot color posters of the cover of that game, which are, of course, Jasper himself seductively staring at the viewer, wearing pantaloons/loincloth/briefs/'TRON Shorts' (depending on the genre), oiled, with a single rose clenched in his teeth.
-Andy
EDIT: Note, in the above situation, there STILL may be rules against having some sort of "roof structure" that "bears a load" and the like. So again, Step One in the "3rd dimension planning" is to check with GenCon rules and the like.
Because, now that I think about it, out of all the GenCons I've attended, I don't recall anyone in the dealer's hall using a roofed structure... and I'm not sure if it's just a "No one else thought of it" thing, or a "They read the fine print and knew it wouldn't fly" thing.
I've also got to side with Andy's reservations about a 2nd story. When Jasper first proposed the idea of "if you want to make something look important, put a frame around around it" I thought we'd be talking about something that wouldn't hold more than a bunch of banners. A kind of archway.
Jasper, since you're more ambitious, how about two pillars that sit on the two outer corners of the booth. Each piller 18-24 in. square. The outsides can hold all kinds of signs, and the one side is a door. Inside are shelves where we keep stock. They're effectively freestanding closets, but they look cooler. Some sort of light archway can connect the two pillars to make the frame you initially spoke of.
BTW, electricity at the con site IIRC, is really, really expensive. Paying hundreds of dollars for mood lighting doesn't seem very cost effective to me.
Andy, you're not going to have to worry about beeing crushed under timber and fat gamers. I'm going to kill you myself. Slowly.
I like the two closets and the high shelf idea. combining these we get
a Frame!!
I find it hard to believe that any state would have a problem with with a raised platform with a safty railing. In any collage campus in the country you'll find theatre sets built by unlicenced students being used in fairly unsafe ways and no one has a problem with that. More likely, if there is a restriction, it's imposed by the commercial enterprise of the situation. I find it hard to believe that we're the first people to think of this. If we are, than by 2006 we're going to have the tower of WotC.
Who wants to take charge of getting the details, like I've been asking for all week. A little research will clear all this up. I just don't have the time. Romeo and Juliet opens tomorrow, time is a myth.
Hiya,
I'll be looking into the details of this and other GenCon notions over the next two weeks.
Best,
Ron
I have sent an email to the GenCon staff asking specifically about the second story. I will let you know what I find out.
Thomas
Quote from: Jasper the MimboI find it hard to believe that any state would have a problem with with a raised platform with a safty railing.
I'd imagine that it has more to do with ADA compliance (non-able attendees would not have access), and liability (an object or person falls from the 2nd story onto an unsuspecting attendee). These concerns may be ameliorated by the temporary nature of the structure, but we won't know for sure until we hear from GenCon administration.
Julie
Thanks for looking into the details for me, guys.
I'll get started on initial drafts on Sunday and hopefully post it for review sometime next week.
Quote from: jrsQuote from: Jasper the MimboI find it hard to believe that any state would have a problem with with a raised platform with a safty railing.
I'd imagine that it has more to do with ADA compliance (non-able attendees would not have access), and liability (an object or person falls from the 2nd story onto an unsuspecting attendee).
Liability I can see as an issue. But I'm guessing that this is covered in the booth costs. That is, already there is the liability that somebody has if somebody trips over your loose booth carpeting and hits their chin on the floor. This is always a concern and probably already covered for "normal" things. Where we get hitched up is in terms of whether or not the second story is covered in the policy. That said, it's not impossible that we might be able to pay an extra premium for the coverage.
No idea what the cost might be. Again, only GenCon can tell us what the deal is there. I'm pessimistic because if it could be done for a reasonable cost, I think it already would have been done. That said, generally I'm optimistic, and think that with some creative thinking that we can work around the problem.
As for the disability problem all we have to do is have one table downstairs for such players and that should ameliorate any concerns there. Again, I'm sure that the Con will have that sort of detail.
Mike
Actually, GenCon asks that exhibitors carry their own insurance, naming GenCon in it and holding them free of any actual liability. Check the fine print :P Gotta love all of the legaleez.
I received a reply from the Jeanette Keblish regarding vertical booth construction.
Quote from: Jeanette KeblishOk I just read through the thread. It sounds very cool but you could not do it with a 10x20. You would have to have an island booth and those start at 20x20. And actually there are ppl that have done it in the past but they received a height variance and only went up about 14 feet. They created a platform for gaming and then used the area under the platform for storage of giveaways, etc. It was not an enclosed space with a 2nd floor though more of a platform. Remember UDE's booth in '03 that is the same sort of concept.
I have to be very careful of line of sight issues with other exhibitors too so keep that in mind. I allowed Rook Steel Storage to do a solid wall one year but they had to be up against a wall to do that.
I do believe there are restrictions for structure building imposed by the Indy Con Ctr. I will check with them on that too.
So, that is where things stand. It sounds like it may be doable, but there is clearly some more information for them to confirm on their end. I think that the answer is pretty comprehensive, but if anything is missing or anyone wants to get more details it would probably be wise to ask here and let me forward the questions. We probably do not want to overwhelm the terribly nice GenCon people with our nagging...
Thomas
Another note from Jeanette:
Quote from: Jeanette KeblishA Multi-story Exhibit is a booth where the display fixtures exceed twelve feet (12'), including Double-decker and Triple-decker Booths. In many cities, a Multi-storied Exhibit requires prior approval by the exhibit facility and/or relevant local government agency because it is deemed to be a "structure" for building purposes. The city building department generally needs to issue a building permit based on an application and drawings prepared and submitted by a licensed architect or engineer. Exhibitors should obtain local building regulations early on to ensure that all time constraints are met. Exhibition organizers should be prepared to assist exhibitors in this application process.
Hurray for ridiculously helpful people!
So, unless we have a liscensed Architect or Engineer in our pocket, it sounds like we can do vertical stuff with two requirements:
1. We have a 20x20 island booth.
2. No part of the structure exceeds 12 feet. I read this as meaning that the guard rails or wall or whatever must come in at 12 feet or slightly below.
So, what to do?
Thomas
Good info, everyone. Since the liability is on the exhibitor, we're free to do whatever we want from that standpoint - taking on whatever liability problems may occur. That is, likely it's the people paying for the booth overall who hold the liability. Which means that it's they that have to decide if it's safe or if they want to actually get insurance, etc.
I'm the sorta crazy zagnut who'd just trust to Jasper's skill to create something safe. But that's just me.
It also sounds like GenCon doesn't mind in principle. Leaving only the convention center restrictions, and the LOS issues. Done properly, I don't see the latter as particularly problematic, as the parts that will be obstructing things will not extend that high. I'm imagining a high railing, but that and the people above won't stand too high. So, if the floor is a reasonable 8 feet off the ground, the total won't much exceed fourteen feet (Jasper, does that sound right?). Making it possible by precedent.
I'm getting very optimistic now.
Mike
Ok, just because we need a 20x20 booth does not mean that we need a 20x20 upper deck.
Jasper, you're now the resident expert on the subject. What sort of problems/advantages would pop up with a 20x20 upper deck. You mentioned needing a center post for support, what else? Additionally, how feasible/desireable would it be to do a 10x20 upper deck that only rose over half of the booth space. This would hopefully reduce the need for expensive lighting and all that...
Also, if we are using a 20x20 booth anyway is there a real need to get extra space up top? If not I would still love to see some elevate banner space and such (those freestanding "closets" sounded pretty cool).
Thomas
Oops, cross posted there.
Thomas, actually that could be read that there is a problem with either any structure over 12 feet, or with any double or triple decker structure. I'm guessing that's the case. In any case, I think that it would be very difficult to make a safe structure that was less than 12 feet tall. Would be very close.
OTOH, the information is ambiguous in a very important way, which is that it says "In some cities." May be that, in fact, Indianapolis is not one of these cities. We'd have to check there.
In any case, if it does happen that we require such an individual, is anyone out there so liscenced? I'm betting we have at least one engineer or architect out there somewhere. If not, I have some friends who have these credentials that I might be able to impose upon. Again, worst case.
Mike
All right! now we're getting somewhere.
So, a 20x20 booth space is fine, but do we have to use a 20x20 top floor also. Could we have a 20x20 space with a 10x20 platform at the back creating a sort of alcove/balcony feel. I'd like to stick to the 10x20 second story for stability reasons and to shy away from to many support beams. Just because we are renting the entire space doesn't mean we have to use it.
If the structure has to be aproved by GenCon and local athorities that backs up the time frame by 4 to 6 weeks to have plenty of time to arange for the inspection.
So, my idea is 20x20 ground floor, 10x20 top floor, at the end of an isle (3 way visibilty) a 9 foot celing with a 3 foot safety rail makes 12 feet. The over all effect of having it layed out like this would be a balcony rather than a second story. I'm picturing a very tavern-like appearance that should appeal to most gamers, especially considering the forge booth atmosphere.
If my hasty calculations are right that will give us about about 430-450 square feet of table space between the upper and lower floors. So much space! so many Demos!
I am going to try to get in touch with the Indianapolis Convention Center to see what kind of regulations they have, and hopefully they will be able to let me know what kind of city ordinances govern this sort of thing. When I know more, you'll know more.
Thomas
The biggest obstacle by far, IMO now, is the increased costs that we're looking at.
QuoteYou would have to have an island booth and those start at 20x20.
That's a different cost from a normal 20x20. Using
last year's prices (this years are not yet published that I'm aware of), that's nearly $1000 more for the booth at least - possibly more.
That's before the cost for building the platform is added on. So once Jasper comes up with a cost and adds it on, the major investors in the booth are going to have to do some hard thinking about whether or not this can go forward.
I still remain optimistic, but I wanted the cost issue to be out there.
Here are the costs of some sizes from last year to give an idea:
Booth Early Comp
Type Dimensions Priority Priority Late Badges
End cap 10X20 $2,400 $2,640 $3,080 4
4-booth peninsula 20X20 $4,750 $5,335 $6,490 8
4-booth island 20X20 $5,620 $6,180 $7,760 8
6-booth island 30X20 $8,000 $8,800 $11,085 12It seems to me that a 10x20 easily gives enough play room above - it's the same size as the entire booth from previous years. Combine that with some tables below (which also takes care of the ADA issue mentioned), and you have twice what we've had previously. While still retaining more than twice the sales space from last year. Basically we'd have triple the room, which sounds like plenty. Quadruple probably wouldn't be worth the cost.
Further, if you ask me, having the booth half covered, and half exposed seems to me to be the best of worlds in terms of creating something eyecatching. That is, with the contrast, people would just have to look and see what was outside, inside, up top.
Mike
Mike
What's the rough estimate for how much the 2nd story would cost in supplies + labor, BTW?
Honestly, I haven't even looked into cost yet. Lumber isn't that expensive, I have access to the tools I'll need, and I don't think I'll even need to pay anyone who'll be helping me. Maybe a case of beer or something. Tell me how much money is being put into this project and I'll tell you what I can do. A budget would be nice so I know what to prioritize for. The most expensive part will probably be transporting it once it's done. No one out here is old enough to rent a U-haul (need to be 25 years old) so someone may need to rent one out there, drive here, load up and go back. Either that or we hire professional movers.
Quote from: Jasper the MimboNo one out here is old enough to rent a U-haul (need to be 25 years old) so someone may need to rent one out there, drive here, load up and go back. Either that or we hire professional movers.
BL> Third option -- we design something that is easily disassemblable and hall it out in someone's van, then assemble it at GenCon.
This assumes a smaller platform.
yrs--
--Ben
This also assumes that someone has time to drive the van all that way before and after the con. That's a few days each way. Do you guys have the ability to make that time committment?
Mike
It will be easily disasembled, that's part of the plan. It will still be quite large. A full size van might cover it, but we are talking a 10x20 platform. Most vans can't accomidate that.
I hadn't planed on bringing it back. It's for GenCon, I'd thought that it would be left in the area so it could be reused or moved around to other cons in the area. I'd figured on a one way trip.