Previous Topics
In First Thoughts

6/2/2008 Maggott: Request for Critiques
Introduction to me and my dark mission: I am Mark Argyle, supreme overlord of GhazPORK Industrial, an incredibly small and slightly deranged entertainment company (both of which are results of…
In First Thoughts
Participants: Maggott, TempvsMortis.

6/2/2008 poireau: My game Resolution system
Well i've pated here my game's Power 16, and I'm still thinking about it. I'm currently working on the seting more than the system. Nontheless, after reading a couple of…
In First Thoughts
Participants: poireau, Kynn.

6/2/2008 Vulpinoid: LARP Concept
I've got a group of friends who've been itching to get back into a live roleplaying game for a few years. Their reasons for wanting this are fairly simple. 1.…
In First Thoughts
Participants: Vulpinoid, David Artman, Capulet, KickAssClown.

6/1/2008 EricAlexander: New game idea: Sports franchise gaming?
I had a vague idea a few days ago that there should be an rpg where the pc's are players on a sports team, whether it be a real life…
In First Thoughts
Participants: EricAlexander, visioNationstudios, Arturo G., Will.

5/30/2008 Mike Welker: Rock 'n' roll: Anything like this out there?
The video game craze, guitar hero stuff, makes me ask this... Anyone know of a rock and roll, or generally pop music sort of thing, rpg of any type? I…
In First Thoughts
Participants: Mike Welker, Marshall Burns, rafial, Thor, EricAlexander.

5/29/2008 davidberg: magical investigation = coloring setting???
I've been playtesting a game that I want to be (a) highly immersive in "sense of place" in the setting, and (b) concerned with discovery of the supernatural.  It hasn't…
In First Thoughts
Participants: davidberg, jag, Marshall Burns.

5/29/2008 GregStolze: It Came to Me In a Dream
No, literally. I woke up this morning having dreamed of a game that was based on ULYSSES. No, I haven't read James Joyce's longest and most-suppressed work, but I guess…
In First Thoughts
Participants: GregStolze, Mike Welker, TempvsMortis, Everspinner, Brendan Day, Momos, Lord_Steelhand, Hermes3, earwig, Ron Edwards.

5/28/2008 3drpg: Web site live, preparing for beta, any thoughts?
Greetings all.  I've browsed these forums on and off for years now and I'm getting ready to release the site for my RPG.  I'm interested in some input on the…
In First Thoughts
Participants: 3drpg, Eero Tuovinen, greyorm, jag.

5/28/2008 Kynn: Heartbreaker! Dreammaker! Lovetaker! Don't you mess around with me!
Anyone else ever finding themselves caught by the urge to just make the most fantasyheartbreakerish fantasy heartbreaker you could make? I keep being tempted. I have no idea why. But…
In First Thoughts
Participants: Kynn, Eero Tuovinen, FrankBrunner, Adam Dray, David Artman, Frank Tarcikowski, Grand_Commander13, Kobayashi, Ron Edwards.

5/27/2008 ChadDubya: Trollkiller: Viking Detective
Trollkiller: Viking Detective (tentative title) Here's the basic guts of an indie-game I've been working on. It's still in its infancy, so any feedback or ideas are appreciated. SYNOPSIS: You…
In First Thoughts
Participants: ChadDubya, whiteknife, dindenver.

5/27/2008 FrankBrunner: [Spellbound Kingdoms] Setting Ideas
I’ve been working out the setting for Spellbound Kingdoms. Right now, the tagline for the game is, “Love, fear, and magic.” If I had to pitch the setting as it…
In First Thoughts
Participants: FrankBrunner, TempvsMortis, Vulpinoid.

5/25/2008 rycanada: Tailored for online play...
[quote=Brennen Reece]Ryan Stoughton! I challenge you to design a game that is tailored for online play![/quote]Alright.  So here's where I have to brush up on my theory and put it…
In First Thoughts
Participants: rycanada, Krippler, Double King, dindenver.

5/22/2008 ghashsnaga: Power 19 Ashcan - At Home (working title)
Hello,   I've been reading here for awhile and I have several ashcan games that have never seen the light of day. So here is one I am interested in…
In First Thoughts
Participants: ghashsnaga, Kaneda, hix.

5/22/2008 TempvsMortis: How to determine difficulty with no GM
This is about that RPG I was talking about before. Okay, so it's GM-less and there's an antagonist-type player who represents the protagonist's obstacles, but since his job is to…
In First Thoughts
Participants: TempvsMortis, Paul Czege, Vulpinoid, Willow, Roadkill, Michael Johnson.

5/21/2008 riotopsys: New game concept unfinished Power 19
I have been wanting to play a character who was a able to change his bodily form at will. I played around with the concept some and came up with…
In First Thoughts
Participants: riotopsys, Greg 1.

5/21/2008 baron samedi: [Tapeworms] an indie rpg taunting indie rpgs
Back in 2003, I wrote a one-page RPG about bowel tapeworms as an inside joke among friends on my lunch hour (60 minutes design in all), the original idea being…
In First Thoughts
Participants: baron samedi, Roadkill, Michael Johnson, Ron Edwards, Will, anansi.

5/20/2008 David Artman: For Mature Audiences [FMA] Reviewer Request
Hi, folks; I have come out of Game Chef with some feedback which is great and some which has be a bit lost. I am seeking some way to "write…
In First Thoughts
Participants: David Artman, dindenver, Illetizgerg, TempvsMortis.

5/20/2008 Paidin: Generic Science Fiction Roleplaying
Greetings! Having recently discovered your forum and perused it for a couple hours now I'd like to say hello and make sure I'm posting in the right area as the…
In First Thoughts
Participants: Paidin, Eero Tuovinen.

5/19/2008 error808: rock-paper-sissors
Hi I've searched the site until I get "server is taking the dog for a walk" message that I get alot here. are there such a thing as rock paper…
In First Thoughts
Participants: error808, Eero Tuovinen, quixoteles, Ken, Capulet, Mike Welker, neko ewen.

5/19/2008 logos7: Re: Post Game Chef Apathy the Calling Looking for Hearts and Minds
Hello Everyone, My name is Joshua MacKay, and I'm just coming out of game chef, with a game half designed and was wondering if I could get some help/reflection upon…
In First Thoughts
Participants: logos7, Ben Lehman, Eero Tuovinen.

<< more previous topics

Subsequent Topics
In First Thoughts

6/3/2008 northerain: [Dark Days]: The Characters
This is for my game ''Dark Days'' (ex-Van Dread) which is about occult investigation and horror. I won't get in on the details since I'm just putting this one idea…
In First Thoughts
Participants: northerain, ChadDubya, Will, anansi, xenopulse.

6/4/2008 Maggott: Maggott's Quest for Critiques, Part 1: The Overview
What follows is the initial part of the Overview section at the beginning of the book I'm writing.  By pagecount it's only one eighth of the total overview, but if…
In First Thoughts
Participants: Maggott, TempvsMortis, Vulpinoid.

6/4/2008 Arturo G.: [My Group of Role-Players] Power-19 of a GameChef entry
Hi everyone! This is the Power-19 for my GameChef entry of this year. Although I'm working in the draft, I would like to know if people find the idea funny…
In First Thoughts
Participants: Arturo G..

6/5/2008 electricpaladin: New Idea: Gods and Demons, Priests and Paladins - Faith and its Consequences
Last time I came here, it was with a game that wasn't really very first thoughtsy. It was basically done, and it's still coming along nicely. But this one (I'm…
In First Thoughts
Participants: electricpaladin, Arturo G., flammifer, Michael Johnson, RadiantWind.

6/5/2008 Illetizgerg: Thoughts on Delayed Success Vs. Failure
Now, personally, I can't stand it when I hear that little kids can't play dodge ball because, good golly miss molly, the idea of last man standing could do nothing…
In First Thoughts
Participants: Illetizgerg, Arturo G., Double King, TempvsMortis, chronoplasm, Will, madunkieg.

6/5/2008 Nybbles: New Idea: Tarot Cards Instead of Dice
the setting i have in mind is a high fantasy RPG set in a world that borrows heavily from myth and fairy tales with celtic, norse and classical roots where…
In First Thoughts
Participants: Nybbles, Will, Peter Nordstrand, charles ferguson, Durand Durand, madunkieg, GregStolze, Double King, chance.thirteen, migo, greyorm, Jack Phillips, Vulpinoid, Big J Money, rasterix.

6/5/2008 chronoplasm: No Power 19 Yet... Some Ideas Though
So I want to make a "hack and slash" where, instead of playing as adventurers on dungeon crawls, players are townsfolk trying to defend and maintain their village. The setting…
In First Thoughts
Participants: chronoplasm, Illetizgerg, Roadkill.

6/5/2008 Maggott: Maggott's Quest for Critiques, part 2: The Klernbraggians
I am posting these race descriptions in order to get an idea of how readers percieve the race according to my description.  The races are unusual enough that there's potential…
In First Thoughts
Participants: Maggott, chronoplasm.

6/7/2008 Big J Money: Before I can begin
I have a specific question concerning goals during game design.  How have some (of you) game designers found that a concious effort to designing a system toward specific GNS goals/rewards…
In First Thoughts
Participants: Big J Money, Eero Tuovinen.

6/11/2008 dindenver: [DNAwesome] Simple Chargen
Hi!   I was trying to come up with a way to make a Supers game without the laundry list of powers. I think I have it, let me know…
In First Thoughts
Participants: dindenver, Arturo G., Filip Luszczyk.

6/12/2008 dindenver: [DNAwesome] Mechanics so far
Hi!   So, this is the starting framework for the mechanics so far: In order to resolve a conflict, we need to know 3 things: 1) What Traits your character…
In First Thoughts
Participants: dindenver, ChadDubya, Will, Arturo G., Filip Luszczyk.

6/13/2008 chronoplasm: Go Fish inspired resolution system
So I'm working on a game where players play as townsfolk in a world full of monsters. Players can play as miners, farmers, merchants, fishermen and many other roles and…
In First Thoughts
Participants: chronoplasm, Paul Czege, Will.

6/14/2008 Grail-Shadowblade: Storm of Beginnings - Character Creation Queries and Thoughts
Bet you didn't expect to see me again folks! Anyway Raid Earth is taking a backburner for now while I focus on a dice based system that my recent D&D…
In First Thoughts
Participants: Grail-Shadowblade.

6/14/2008 Bullbar: A very, very narrow concept: The Bridge/The Drop
I'm not entirely sure if this is the right way to go about it, but I hope so. I've come up with a concept for a game set entirely between…
In First Thoughts
Participants: Bullbar, Arturo G., Vulpinoid, Everspinner, madunkieg, Will, jag, RadiantWind.

6/14/2008 Roadkill: 7 phrases
Ok this is not designed to be a serious game or even a game at all, just a light hearted idea/piece of fun perhaps. It could be played within an…
In First Thoughts
Participants: Roadkill, Vulpinoid, Willow, Will.

6/16/2008 Jumanji83: Corporate sell-out
So I've been thinking, and there is a game I'd like to design (it would be my first if I ever get around to it). The players' characters are all…
In First Thoughts
Participants: Jumanji83, Will, Ron Edwards.

6/16/2008 ChrisMcDee: Inheritance - High-Powered Heroes of Classical Antiquity
I can't help but feel Connections was the wrong place to put this, so for your general feedback consideration here is Inheritance! Inheritance is a System…
In First Thoughts
Participants: ChrisMcDee, preludetotheend.

6/18/2008 ChrisMcDee: Teen-Islanders High School Politics and Coconut Radios
I was toying with the idea of creating a game that could be playable solo, taking inspiration from the randomly generated content of Roguelikes. I ended up with the idea…
In First Thoughts
Participants: ChrisMcDee, whiteknife.

6/19/2008 evancolson: Power 19 concept
I'm a real first-timer here and after reading a few other people's posts, I have decided to sketch out a "Power 19" for a game I'm thinking of creating. Criticism…
In First Thoughts
Participants: evancolson, matthijs, dindenver.

6/19/2008 Will: [Surreality Engine] call for comments on system.
Ok, I have been writing and rewriting this for long enough and I know exactly how it should work and it plays quite well with me running it, it's time…
In First Thoughts
Participants: Will, tombowings.

more subsequent topics >>