Previous Topics
In Indie Game Design

11/24/2005 FlameLover: [Myrkwell] Need help with first RPG
Well i've been working on an RPG for abit now and i've got numerous decisions to make, the two biggest being classes vs. no-classes and what type of die to…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: FlameLover, cpeterso, Arturo G., Roger, Tony Irwin, Jasper, preludetotheend, Trevis Martin, dindenver, Troy_Costisick, Arpie, xenopulse, Adam Dray.

11/22/2005 Malcolm: [Cold City] - Mechanical Basics
Following on from these two threads: Cold City: Character Creation: http://www.indie-rpgs.com/forum/index.php?topic=17325.0 Cold City: Revised Character Creation & Consequences: http://www.indie-rpgs.com/forum/index.php?topic=17512.0 I thought it wise to gain feedback on the mechanical elements…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: Malcolm, Roger, Noon, PrzeSzkoda, mutex.

11/22/2005 nikola: [Shock:] Livening up resolution
In a discussion with Vincent last weekend about resolution in Shock:, and we identified some problems, but not really any solutions. So I'd like some assistance. First off, if you…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: nikola, Jonathan Hastings, Tim Alexander, TonyLB, lumpley.

11/22/2005 AmbroseCollector: [Pentanima] Initiative and Turns
I've been writing a game for about a month, now, and have a good 55 pages of material, but there are problems I routinely encounter when running battles. The resolution…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: AmbroseCollector, TonyLB.

11/20/2005 hix: [Dirty Virgins] Fixing the voting mechanism
I’ve written a game called Dirty Virgins which is designed to be played over a couple of hours. As Rob said over at the 20x20 Room, it’s about medieval maidens…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: hix, TonyLB, jasonm, nikola.

11/19/2005 tygertyger: [Alien Angels] Game Mechanics Adjustments
I have started the reworking of AA and already I've hit a snag.  Here's the deal; Ron suggested that the dice pool for task resolution was a bad idea (which…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: tygertyger, Ron Edwards, Arturo G., Christopher Weeks.

11/19/2005 darrick: second edition of Satanis
hey everybody, now i've seen this trial run, this dress rehearsal, and it has shown me much... yes, releasing Empire of Satanis (dark fantasy/horror) taught me a lot of things. …
In Indie Game Design
Participants: darrick, Jasper, komradebob, Jared A. Sorensen, Sean.

11/19/2005 Rusty: [Space Rat] Rewards for Femme Babes
Let me start by throwing out a general "thanks" to everyone that has given me feedback on Space Rat so far.  "Thanks".  Now, down to the pointy end of things…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: Rusty, Rob MacDougall, Graham Walmsley, Ron Edwards.

11/17/2005 cpeterso: [Firestarter] November Ronnies entry
Firestarter sprung to life as a last-minute entry for the November 2005 Ronnies competition. This is my first attempt to design a role-playing game and it is admittedly incomplete. I…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: cpeterso.

11/17/2005 timfire: [In a Land Called] New Skool Sim
Currently there's a new round of Sim debate over in the GNS forum. As usual, there are calls for people to design new games that incorporate current ideas about Sim.…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: timfire, Mike Holmes, komradebob, Caldis, Tony Irwin, Aman the Rejected.

11/17/2005 TonyPace: [Holomodor] Not Just Another Ronnies Thread
[url=http://www.1km1kt.net/rpg/Holodomor.php]Holomodor[/url] is a long way from just another RPG. I don't know if I could play it, I don't know if anybody [i]should[/i] play it, but it's quite a frightening…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: TonyPace, James Holloway, CSBone, Sambucus, PrzeSzkoda.

11/17/2005 Troy_Costisick: [Cutthroat] Revised Edition!
Heya, First off let me thank James from Blankshield Press for lending me a hand by hosting my pdf document.  Give his site a once over if you get a…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: Troy_Costisick, TonyLB.

11/17/2005 Frank T: [Delete] Another Ronnies Feedback Thread
[url=http://www.1km1kt.net/rpg/Delete.pdf]Delete[/url], by Brandon Parigo, really got me with that teaser and introduction. God has deleted you because you’re such a damn loser, and now there’s mud oozing out of your…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: Frank T, TonyPace, inoir.

11/17/2005 hix: [apocalypse girl] Unofficial Ronnies feedback
[url=http://www.1km1kt.net/rpg/Apocalypse_Girl.php][b]apocalypse girl[/b][/url] had an instantaneously appealing hook to me: [quote]God chose you to save the world. Congrats. Here's the thing: Nobody gave you any superpowers. You get no Slayer strength,…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: hix, Ben Lehman, Sydney Freedberg, Ron Edwards, Tobias, TonyLB, Unco Lober, Ramidel, Roger, Frank T.

11/17/2005 heironymous: [Stake] rough partial first draft
Here: http://www.malcontentgames.com/stake.pdf Thanks for looking!
In Indie Game Design
Participants: heironymous, Jasper, Ron Edwards, TonyLB, AmbroseCollector.

11/16/2005 Halzebier: [Kpachoapmee / Krasnoarmeets] Enemy at the Ronnies Gates
Hi there! I've been holding off on posting regarding the November Ronnies because " First Impressions" (http://www.indie-rpgs.com/forum/index.php?topic=17576.0) didn't garner many responses and I feared I…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: Halzebier, Jared A. Sorensen, Gregor Hutton, James Holloway, komradebob, Dumirik, TonyPace, contracycle, Sydney Freedberg, mutex.

11/16/2005 talysman: [The Saint's Golem vs. The Devil's Dragon] comments on November Ronnies entry
since Ron suggested this time that everyone, not just people "sitting out" this round of the Ronnies, should help start thoughtful analysis of the Ronnies submissions, I figured I'd start…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: talysman, Tobias, Sydney Freedberg.

11/16/2005 joepub: Point of Collapse game
Okay, contained is the small core game outline (5-6 pages long)... I've also included a quick outline of the history of the world, just to give you an idea of…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: joepub, Troy_Costisick, TonyLB, Mike Holmes.

11/16/2005 CrookedBroomstick: [Shattered Earth] Trying to spot obvious issues and suggestions
I'm new to the forum and I'd like to place my idea up on the chopping block.  Been needing some kind of feedback on the general premise of the mechanic. …
In Indie Game Design
Participants: CrookedBroomstick, TonyPace, Matt Wilson.

11/14/2005 GreatWolf: [Dynasties] Looking for source material for multi-generational RPG design
Hi, everyone!  Recently I was waxing eloquent about the aborted Pendragon campaign that I was in with my wife and Ralph Mazza (Ralph doing GM duties).  One of the aspects…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: GreatWolf, talysman, Shreyas Sampat, Blake Hutchins, TonyPace.

<< more previous topics

Subsequent Topics
In Indie Game Design

11/26/2005 tonyd: [Magicians of England] Balancing Rewards
Thanks to everyone who helped out on my other thread. I was able to come up with some good adjustments to Magicians of England. Magicians is a gamemasterless narrative game…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: tonyd, mutex, Roger.

11/27/2005 hix: [Dirty Virgins] Starting Honour & Shame
Dirty Virgins (which’ll probably get renamed Desperate Virgins) is a game about maidens trying to sully their reputations before a dragon eats them in the morning. In a previous thread…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: hix, TonyLB, Sydney Freedberg, dindenver.

11/28/2005 Profit: A-Team RPG
I have a burning wish for some A-Team (the Tv-series) roleplaying, but need a solid (or at least, as solid as you would want them for a one-shot goof session) …
In Indie Game Design
Participants: Profit, Eero Tuovinen, Jared A. Sorensen, Noon, natman, cpeterso, mutex, Joshua BishopRoby, contracycle, xenopulse, jerry.

11/28/2005 heironymous: [Stake] near-final version and GM-less
I've posted a more complete version of Stake at the usual spot: http://www.malcontentgames.com/stake.pdf General comments welcome, bur I'm particularly interested in discussion of the "GM less" rules. The only other…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: heironymous, Jasper, TonyLB.

11/28/2005 Hereward The Wake: The use of Runes in a RPG
I've been working on the idea of using runes as a way for a game to be guided. Runes can be used in a similar way to tarot so should…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: Hereward The Wake, talysman, J Tolson, nikola, Hermes3, Darcy Burgess.

11/28/2005 Sean: [Class/Level Fantasy Game] Spell Deck Mechanics
Hi there - At http://1.myfreebulletinboard.com/calithena-forum-12.html&sid=325f0a890ce28415737f2f10a0411369 I've been trying to get a game out of my system. I was looking for feedback in particular on the following mechanic. The idea is…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: Sean, mutex, Kesher.

11/30/2005 AChicony: Tolkein must be rolling in his grave
So I’m in the games shop flicking through the new Lord of the Rings RPG and KAPOW!!! It hits me like a tonne of Balrog turd! What is this shite???…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: AChicony, Eero Tuovinen, Ron Edwards.

11/30/2005 Malckuss: First time here, please be gentle. (long)
This is my first post ever here. I'm very hip to the lingo, so I apologize in advance for my seemingly plebeian ways. I have a game I've been working…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: Malckuss, Joshua BishopRoby, TonyLB, dindenver.

11/30/2005 timfire: [Mexican Standoff] A Party Game for You, Your Friends, & a Pile of Money
A while ago there was where different people, including myself, posted some ideas for a "Resevoir Dogs"-style Mexican Standoff RPG. I've since developed my ideas some more, and…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: timfire, xenopulse, Joshua BishopRoby, TonyLB, GreatWolf, Troy_Costisick, Eero Tuovinen, Matt, WonderLlama.

12/1/2005 alejandro: Market Share
is there anyway to determine what the market share is like for the major players, d20, WW, Gurps, etc?
In Indie Game Design
Participants: alejandro, Eero Tuovinen.

12/1/2005 dindenver: [LoL]
Hi!   Lands of Lore is the name of a CRPG, here are other possible names I am thinking of using: <a href="mailto:DInDenver@yahoo.com?Subject=Legends of Lanasia">Legends of Lanasia</a> <a href="mailto:DInDenver@yahoo.com?Subject=Legends of…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: dindenver, Troy_Costisick, Eero Tuovinen, John Harper, Malckuss, Mark Johnson.

12/2/2005 Troy_Costisick: Learn from my mistakes
Heya, I’ve been going over several design threads lately both here and on RPGnet.  There are some common questions I see newer designers raise that in the end, really don’t…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: Troy_Costisick, Joshua BishopRoby, inthisstyle, Paul Czege, dindenver, FlameLover, TonyLB, Dumirik.

12/2/2005 Levi Kornelsen: Preparing to revise.
This is a game of mine which I'm thinking of revising again to make it more of an RPG again, and less of an Adventure game (the direction I was…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: Levi Kornelsen, Malckuss, dindenver, sayter, TonyLB, Mark Woodhouse, Sean, J Tolson, FlameLover.

12/2/2005 sayter: [Realm] Character Types (semi-poll)
I was discussing with some of my friends the other day about the game. They have been giving aid in areas relating to proof-reading and ideas as I go along.…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: sayter, dindenver, Archer, 1of3, joepub, Ramidel, Calithena, Bill Masek.

12/2/2005 Jonas Karlsson: [One Can Have Her] Character Creation and Conflict Resolution
I've been working and re-working my September Ronnies game One Can Have Her, trying to get it to do what I want without loosing what's good. This has made my…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: Jonas Karlsson, Joshua BishopRoby, Emily Care.

12/2/2005 Joshua BishopRoby: [FLFS] Scrip Format
This is continuing in the vein of Reward System At Last! and partially triggered by Eetu's comments in I'm Surprised. System in question in short: Every character has…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: Joshua BishopRoby, TonyLB, LordSmerf, Ice Cream Emperor.

12/2/2005 xenopulse: [Beast Hunters of Chel'qhur] It's All About the Challenge
Well, I just lost my long post on this because something closed my browser window.  So this one will be shorter.  I hope it'll still catch your interest, because I'm…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: xenopulse, Noon, Joshua BishopRoby, Clinton R. Nixon, jasonm.

12/2/2005 dindenver: [LoL] New name round 2
Hi!   I guess since there is a Legends of Alyria game, here's a new round of naming suggestions, please tell me which you think is cooler: Legends of Lore…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: dindenver, Ben Lehman, Malcolm, Troy_Costisick, GreatWolf.

12/3/2005 JSDiamond: All's quiet --bag o' drafts
Here are the drafts for all three booklets in pdf form.  Try them out if you like. Just remember that they are rough drafts.  All feedback appreciated. http://www.orbit-rpg.com/alls_Quiet_rules.pdf  --this is…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: JSDiamond.

12/3/2005 Eric Bennett: Lovecraftian design
Hello there, everyone, I haven't been around since my splurt on Hearths, mostly because a computer error shortly thereafter wiped both that and almost four months of RP logs from…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: Eric Bennett, TonyLB, dindenver, Arpie, mutex, Mark Woodhouse, sayter, CPXB, Ethesis.

more subsequent topics >>