Previous Topics

3/4/2003 ThreeGee: Does Setting Matter?
Hey all, In this thread about system, the point was raised that the majority of gamers (at least the vocal ones on another board) think that setting is the single…
In RPG Theory
Participants: ThreeGee, Ron Edwards, Matt Wilson, Mike Holmes, Valamir, contracycle, Bankuei, Rob Donoghue, Clinton R. Nixon, Alan, clehrich, Le Joueur, John Kim, DaGreatJL, simon_hibbs, M. J. Young, Blake Hutchins.

3/4/2003 Matt Wilson: Is my game N/S or just S?
The game I'm working on has no overtly stated N Premise. Does that exclude it from being a N game entirely? I had this idea from an interview with Joss…
In GNS Model Discussion
Participants: Matt Wilson, Mike Holmes.

3/4/2003 Matt Snyder: It's the system, stupid
I've had several polite, shall we say, disagreements with my fellow players about whether system does indeed matter. Their positions are all over the "spectrum" from matters to doesn'tmatter. Obviously,…
In RPG Theory
Participants: Matt Snyder, Le Joueur, Paganini, ThreeGee, Ron Edwards, Mike Holmes, Matt Wilson, Sylus Thane, jburneko, Walt Freitag, clehrich.

3/4/2003 Tony Irwin: Author Stance
Folks I need some help, I'm trying to read up on games that encourage players to take author stance rather than actor stance. I'm especially interested in games that make…
In RPG Theory
Participants: Tony Irwin, Valamir, Mike Holmes, Bankuei, Ron Edwards, M. J. Young, Bruce Baugh, Ben Morgan.

2/27/2003 Jack Spencer Jr: Morale and identification [split from Wargames]
Man, I'll tell you. I'm not much of a wargamer at all. Mostly because I just cannot treat any of my units as cannon fodder. I just can't march a…
In RPG Theory
Participants: Jack Spencer Jr, contracycle, Thierry Michel, Mike Holmes, clehrich, arxhon, Valamir.

3/4/2003 Michael S. Miller: Running Indie Games at Smaller Cons
Well, the Sorcerer game I was scheduled to run at A Gazebo of Games did not actually run. I only had one player sign-up and he showed up 15 minutes…
In Actual Play
Participants: Michael S. Miller, Alambr1, Ron Edwards, jdagna, Andy Kitkowski, Demonspahn, Mike Holmes, abzu.

3/4/2003 arxhon: Elucidating GNS via microcosm situations?
This might not be the appropriate forum for this, but i'm asking about GNS so.... I was running a game of WFRP last year (ducks hurled refuse from the Nar-gang),…
In GNS Model Discussion
Participants: arxhon, clehrich, Ron Edwards, Valamir, Mike Holmes, M. J. Young, Bob McNamee.

3/4/2003 Paganini: [Cornerstone] To Mars and Back
We just wrapped up a three session IRC playtest of Cornerstone in a Wellsian Victorian Sci-fi setting. These were very instructive sessions, as we drifted and tweaked the game slightly…
In Actual Play
Participants: Paganini, Trevis Martin, Bob McNamee, C. Edwards, Mike Holmes.

3/4/2003 anonymouse: Paladin: new edition/rewrite?
Clinton, I've seen you mention the fact that you're working on a rewrite/new edition of Paladin in a few threads. Is there an official status to this, or it's just…
In CRN Games
Participants: anonymouse, Clinton R. Nixon, Bob McNamee, Tony Irwin.

3/4/2003 jrs: Le Mon Mouri Questions
As mentioned in the Two at once! thread, we’ve played two sessions of Le Mon Mouri. I’ve been wanting to play Le Mon Mouri since Ron…
In Actual Play
Participants: jrs, sdemory, Ron Edwards.

3/3/2003 Steve Dustin: octaNe soundtrack
So I'm preparing my octaNe soundtrack for my octaNe game in a couple of weeks. I'm taking the Rule of Rock'n'Roll very seriously. Anyway, I've got it all worked up…
In Memento-Mori Theatricks
Participants: Steve Dustin, Jared A. Sorensen, quozl, Valamir, Mike Holmes, clehrich, Rob MacDougall, Ron Edwards, Matt Snyder.

3/3/2003 Garbanzo: Ashen: Concerns about handling time
I’m knee-deep into a design (Ashen). I‘ve got mechanics that support my premise, but I’m wishing there was less handling time involved. Specifically, any total comes from adding two attributes,…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: Garbanzo, Mike Holmes, Matt Gwinn, szilard, Palaskar.

3/3/2003 Matt Gwinn: Who Uses the Forge the most?
[b]The Forge[/b] has continues to grow by leaps and bounds over the past year, but I haven't really noticed a huge swell in posts. As of this post, we have…
In Site Discussion
Participants: Matt Gwinn, Mark Johnson, Trevis Martin, Jack Spencer Jr, Jürgen Mayer, dalek_of_god, Valamir, Mike Holmes, M. J. Young, Piratecat, Pyske, Psycho42, Jeph.

3/3/2003 Sylus Thane: Exploring the Narrative of the Simulated Gamist world
I know the following could just as easily fit within the Actual Play forum but I feel the overall gist of what I am about to talk about is better…
In GNS Model Discussion
Participants: Sylus Thane, Mike Holmes, Ron Edwards.

3/3/2003 Matt Gwinn: Kazaa, Piracy & Your PDF game
I was recently introduced to Kazaa Lite, which is a file sharing program similar to napster. I've found that you can find nearly everything on there that is in a…
In Publishing
Participants: Matt Gwinn, Jared A. Sorensen, Valamir, Stuart DJ Purdie, Ryan Wynne, talysman, yellow_skeleton, quozl, Le Joueur, Ron Edwards, Paganini, GMSkarka, Mike Holmes, Matt Snyder, iago, contracycle, Quixotica.

3/3/2003 Paul Czege: # of review copies
Hey everyone, This is a question for folks who gave out review copies of their printed games at conventions last year. As I go forward with plans for a small…
In Publishing
Participants: Paul Czege, Jared A. Sorensen, Matt Gwinn, geekspeakweekly.

3/3/2003 Matt Gwinn: 3E Character Creation Session
Once again, I tried to introduce my D&D group to something I picked up here at the Forge...the Character Creation Session. First off, we had been playing the same D&D…
In Actual Play
Participants: Matt Gwinn, Clay, Bankuei, Valamir, Ron Edwards, hardcoremoose, jdagna, Steve Dustin.

3/3/2003 tauman: Magic Items
Okay, now don't everyone get excited--I'm not talking about handing out so many that the characters all glow like Christmas trees... Many of the fantasy novels that have inspired me…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: tauman, Valamir, Drew Stevens, Jake Norwood, Ron Edwards, Salamander, Durgil, Mike Holmes, Brian Leybourne, Spartan, TAROT, Bob McNamee, Ashren Va'Hale, Paka, Bob Richter, contracycle, Jason Kottler, Daredevil.

3/3/2003 Drew Stevens: GNS- Questioning Gamist
Hooray for random shower tangential thoughts! Verification: The primary Gamist goal for playing a game is they want to Win. They are playing to try and beat someone, either the…
In GNS Model Discussion
Participants: Drew Stevens, quozl, Ron Edwards, Valamir, Jack Spencer Jr, Walt Freitag, ethan_greer, Mike Holmes, lumpley, M. J. Young, greyorm, talysman, JMendes.

3/3/2003 Michael Hopcroft: When does a design cease to be indie?
When does a designer or a publisher lose his indie-cred round these parts? I'm getting kind of worried now that I have a D20 project in the works and will…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: Michael Hopcroft, Maurice Forrester, Spooky Fanboy, Clinton R. Nixon.

<< more previous topics

Subsequent Topics

3/4/2003 iago: Abstracted Paladin Orders
I was pleased to come to this forum today and find that an idea that had been banging around in my head had already been discussed ("A Paladin on the…
In CRN Games
Participants: iago.

3/4/2003 MistHunter: Most popular RPG genre...
I've been thinking about making an indie RPG for a long time, and multiple genres have crossed my mind, but I haven't come up with the right genre! Now I…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: MistHunter, Le Joueur, xiombarg, quozl, Valamir, ethan_greer, Mike Holmes, Spooky Fanboy, M. J. Young, Balbinus, Ron Edwards, Gold Rush Games, Allan.

3/4/2003 iago: Paladin at Three Feet Tall
Outside of adapting some of my favorite genres (Amber, Buffy, and other letters further down the alphabet), I've really been enjoying the writing exercise that Paladin proposes in terms of…
In CRN Games
Participants: iago, Jason L Blair, Jonathan Walton.

3/4/2003 Opsimath: Any freelance RPG editors out there?
A piece of advice I've heard more than once is that when writing, you should never attempt to be your own editor. Sounds like good advice. How do you go…
In Publishing
Participants: Opsimath, quozl.

3/4/2003 svenlein: interesting musket article
People have talked before about getting Muskets for flower of battle. Here is a nice article about it. Check the sources let us know if you feel they are untrustworthy.…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: svenlein.

3/4/2003 jdagna: Paladin for Moral Relativists
Iago's recent posts gave me an idea that might make Paladin better suited for moral relativists. What if you get rid of the concept of orders and give each Paladin…
In CRN Games
Participants: jdagna, iago, Ron Edwards, b_bankhead, Rob Donoghue.

3/4/2003 Nev the Deranged: Question
If I have game designs that are non-RPGs (say, board games, card games, live action games, tile games, miniatures games, etc.) where would it be appropriate to post about them?…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: Nev the Deranged, ghoest.

3/4/2003 Opsimath: Any freelance RPG editors out there?
(reposted from the Publishing forum) A piece of advice I've heard more than once is that when writing, you should never attempt to be your own editor. Sounds like good…
In Connections
Participants: Opsimath, quozl, arkcure, Simon Ringwood, talysman, ThreeGee, Ron Edwards, Tar Markvar, minipainterUS, Dav.

3/5/2003 Matt Wilson: TV show offshoot idea
This game I'm working on depicts a space adventure TV show. While brainstorming ideas, I came up with a few that would work better as some sort of InSpectres spinoff.…
In Memento-Mori Theatricks
Participants: Matt Wilson, Jared A. Sorensen, Mike Holmes, Jason L Blair.

3/5/2003 Sidhain: Game Writer's take heed--a bit of a rant.
I purchased Paladin a week or so ago, but finally got down to printing it out and reading it this week. Now, this goes to design specifically. Write /more/. Paladin…
In Publishing
Participants: Sidhain, Matt Snyder, Mark Johnson, Mike Holmes, Bob McNamee, Paganini, iago, M. J. Young, Clinton R. Nixon, Ryan Wynne, Bankuei, clehrich, Jake Norwood, Jared A. Sorensen, quozl, GMSkarka, Rob Donoghue, Valamir, lumpley, Ron Edwards.

3/5/2003 Stuart DJ Purdie: Ordering of play elements
[quote="Ron Edwards"]Of course Setting matters. Without characters, setting, situation, a system, and color, role-playing isn't happening.[/quote] Read this over in the setting matter thread, and it crystalised something that I've…
In RPG Theory
Participants: Stuart DJ Purdie, Ron Edwards, Emily Care.

3/5/2003 iago: Delta: A bit of a collision?
I've been thinking about Sorceror, and I've been thinking about Paladin. Paladin I've read, and Sorceror, I've at least had someone who's read it describe a lot of the elements…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: iago, Spooky Fanboy.

3/5/2003 Aaron: When pets go bad
Now I know that the "official" rules for Pack animals will be coming out in OBAM but for anyone interested in using these kind of animals, dogs wolves, lions etc,…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Aaron.

3/5/2003 Aaron: Tough life being a giant?
Giants have a pretty rough deal when it comes to domestic arguments in TROS! All one giant has to do is slap the other with a measly 1pt success margin…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Aaron, svenlein, tauman, Mike Holmes, Bob Richter, Brian Leybourne, Noon, Jake Norwood, Durgil, Shadeling, Ashren Va'Hale.

3/5/2003 RobMuadib: TMW:COTEC - "GC: Metaplay" excerpt
Hi all I am still flailing about working on the chapter formerly known as game concepts: shared play, which i have at the moment changed to metaplay. Anyway, i have…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: RobMuadib, Ron Edwards, Le Joueur, Mike Holmes.

3/5/2003 Cryostorm: Union - ToS: Website Discusion 3-5-03
Hi, Cameron Harsh Here This thread is to discuss the March 5th website update of Union Tides of Steel. If you don't know about our game check out our other…
In Indie Game Design
Participants: Cryostorm, Spooky Fanboy, Mike Holmes, Harsh Attack, RobMuadib.

3/5/2003 Mark Johnson: Fate of Free PDFs
[quote="iago"][quote="LordX"]Disregarding Paladin, would you be adverse to spending $6 for a fully playable 32 page PDF containing merely system and chargen if there were support PDF products (setting, adventures, etc)…
In Publishing
Participants: Mark Johnson, Sidhain, Paganini, Mike Holmes, Ron Edwards, Gold Rush Games, Paul Czege, Adam.

3/5/2003 richks: Question of how to present information. One book or many?
This has probably come up a number of times, but I'm trying to decide the best way to make Urban Mythos available. The first release will be a free PDF,…
In Publishing
Participants: richks, clehrich, Mike Holmes, Matt Wilson.

3/5/2003 Jared A. Sorensen: NEW OCTANE ROLES HERE PLEASE.
Just a request that all new Roles for octaNe go in this thread. Thanks! - J
In Memento-Mori Theatricks
Participants: Jared A. Sorensen, Spooky Fanboy, Colin Chapman, Derek Devlin, b_bankhead.

3/5/2003 ethan_greer: What makes a game it's own thing?
So. I'm hard at work on a "new" RPG. I'm quite pleased with what I have so far, and more information will of course be forthcoming as it approaches drafthood.…
In RPG Theory
Participants: ethan_greer, Ron Edwards, Mike Holmes.

more subsequent topics >>