Previous Topics
In The Riddle of Steel

12/14/2002 Bob Richter: Defensive Grappling.
Anyone else ever notice how crazy this is? I toss a 2-die probing attack. My opponent tosses a 10-die defensive grapple. He wins, of course, and puts me down hard,…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Bob Richter, Jake Norwood, Mokkurkalfe, Aaron, MrGeneHa, Brian Leybourne, Lyrax, Wolfen, Vanguard.

12/14/2002 Jake Norwood: New Review
For those of you that read Polish, here's a new (and, as always, positive) review of TROS. http://rpg.gildia.com/systemy/_inne/riddle_of_steel/riddle_of_steel The last paragraph says that the review very strongly reccomends the game…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Jake Norwood, prophet118.

12/13/2002 Durgil: Thoughts on Fatigue
I had an idea today at work about the Fatigue rules in TRoS that I want to share with everyone on the list. This is just an outline of my…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Durgil, Mokkurkalfe, Wolfen.

12/13/2002 contracycle: finally got it
So, I FINALLY got a copy of TROS. Just thought I'd share my opinion now that I can see the real beast. I've not read all of it yet. I…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: contracycle, Jake Norwood, Brian Leybourne, Ron Edwards, Valamir, Mokkurkalfe.

12/12/2002 Brian Leybourne: Combat Sim update
In a burst of enthusiasm born from boredom at work I started doing some extra development on the combat sim. So far, I have fixed Dual Rapiers not being able…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Brian Leybourne, prophet118, Bob Richter, svenlein, Mokkurkalfe, Aaron, toli, Lucien Black, Valamir, Wolfen, Jake Norwood.

12/11/2002 prophet118: Challenging Players Notions
lately i have found myself wondering exactly how and what i should do to challenge the players preconceived notions of what a game should be.. that basically means that i…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: prophet118, Bankuei, Mike Holmes, Ron Edwards, Mokkurkalfe, Jaeger, Jake Norwood, ShaneNINE, Bob Richter, Lucien Black, Irmo.

12/11/2002 Jabberwocky: Clarification of combat with multiple opponants...
As is, the rules just say 'split the CP between the opponents'. How exactly does this work... does it mean that if you are the aggressor you may take two…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Jabberwocky, prophet118, Lyrax, Jake Norwood, Shadeling, Warboss Grock.

12/9/2002 Wolfen: An idea for the forum
I just had a thought that might reduce the amount of redundant discussions, and threads shot down when someone points out that it's been discussed before. Jake, you could have…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Wolfen, Brian Leybourne, Mike Holmes, Jake Norwood.

12/9/2002 MrGeneHa: Spike, arrow, and rapier damage
Hey all, this is just my take on weapon damage. Disclaimer: I don't modern fence, historical sword fight, SCA, and haven't made any special study of wounds and penetration. Anyhoo,…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: MrGeneHa, prophet118, Brian Leybourne, Bob McNamee, Jake Norwood, Bob Richter, toli.

12/9/2002 Mask-of-Winters: Armor of Air
Hiya gang-- Just wondering if this is going to be an errata issue or not. The Duration component of the Armor of Air spell is listed as 1, which I…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Mask-of-Winters, spunky.

12/9/2002 Lucien Black: thoughts for optional attribute designation...
I was thinking about the idea of character appearance and how attributes factor into that, and was wondering if anyone had any ideas for generating stats based on appearance, as…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Lucien Black, prophet118, Wolfen.

12/8/2002 prophet118: Question on Different Types of Magic
ok... so how would i go about using elemental magic, shielding magic....i think thats the only two i need to know about
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: prophet118, Jake Norwood, Enoch, Irmo, Brian Leybourne, Lucien Black, Stephen, Lyrax, Vanguard, spunky, Bob Richter, Ron Edwards.

12/7/2002 prophet118: website is down
uhhh well the title really says it all, when i go to www.theriddleofsteel.net, i get the dotregister page
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: prophet118, Jake Norwood, Brian Leybourne, Irmo.

12/7/2002 Ben Lehman: TN 11 -- does it cause a problem?
So, one of the quirks of the TROS system is that TN 11 and TN 10 are functionally the same (if you open-end on a 10, then you must at…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Ben Lehman, prophet118, Mask-of-Winters, Bob Richter, MrGeneHa, toli, MikeSands, Lyrax, Warboss Grock, Durgil, Jake Norwood, Henry Fitch, Brian Leybourne.

12/6/2002 toli: Char Gen, Priorities, Randomness
The discussion RE insight got me thinking about this subject. I was curious why you (Jake) decided to for a deterministic as opposed to random form of character generation. I've…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: toli, prophet118, Mike Holmes, Bankuei, Irmo, Jake Norwood, Ron Edwards, Bob Richter.

12/6/2002 prophet118: Insight Question
ok... when you get enough to have extra priorities with characters... like say you had 3 extra A's, would you get: A,A,A,A,E,F or A,A,A,A,B,C,D,E,F i think its the first one,…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: prophet118, Mokkurkalfe, Irmo, Brian Leybourne, Jake Norwood.

12/6/2002 Bankuei: Unstated bits of TROS
TROS, like any good fighter, is sneaky. It looks pretty straightforward, then folks starting finding out a lot of the rules and ideas in it are just a feint, counter…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Bankuei, prophet118, Jake Norwood, Mike Holmes, Wolfen, ShaneNINE, Brian Leybourne, LordIvan, Ben Lehman, Salamander, Jason Kottler, MattFW, Kaare Berg, Jasper the Mimbo, Valamir, Lxndr, Overdrive, Paka, Ron Edwards, Morfedel, Lebo77, Spartan, Ashren Va'Hale.

12/6/2002 ShaneNINE: Missile Pool
Do I have this straight? The more dice you have in your missile pool the longer it takes to get to your full potential? That doesn't seem right.
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: ShaneNINE, prophet118, Jake Norwood.

12/6/2002 ShaneNINE: House Rule Question
Will a house rule like the following screw up the game? If you have x amount of dice in your pool (this isn't for combat, btw, but other skills) you…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: ShaneNINE, prophet118, Mike Holmes, Jake Norwood, MrGeneHa.

12/4/2002 Ben Lehman: The Doomed Hero
(don't have my book right now, as it's on loan, so if this is covered in the book I apologize) So something that came up in making a character with…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Ben Lehman, Brian Leybourne, MrGeneHa.

<< more previous topics

Subsequent Topics
In The Riddle of Steel

12/16/2002 Mokkurkalfe: A few things...
Played this weekend and a few things came me up. * What's the best defence(s) against an evasive attack, if someone uses it instead of defending himself? * What's the…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Mokkurkalfe, Bob Richter, Brian Leybourne, Lyrax, Jake Norwood, Ron Edwards, Warboss Grock.

12/17/2002 vegasthroat: Conquest on the History Channel
Tonight's Episode of Conquest on The History Channel (MON DEC 16th) was a great little primer on medieval weapons and armor. With the narrator actually using the weapons and piercing…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: vegasthroat, Lyrax.

12/19/2002 Merritt Baggett: Combat Sim Discussion (Split from previous thread)
That said, I may have missed it earlier in this thread or elsewhere, but is the combat sim going to eventually be Flower of Battle compatible, or kept to just…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Merritt Baggett, prophet118, Brian Leybourne, Mokkurkalfe, Aaron, Jake Norwood.

12/20/2002 Clinton R. Nixon: Looking for the right location on Weryth
I'm thinking of running another game of The Riddle of Steel, but am having problems finding a location that fits what I'm looking for. I'm trying to find a large…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Clinton R. Nixon, Ashren Va'Hale, Jake Norwood, Ville, MrGeneHa, Lyrax.

12/20/2002 rikiwarren: Confusion about the world
The book makes references to Otamarluk/Dardanet conflicts, yet when I look at the map there appears to be a large land mass between them (Taveruun). I read through the description…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: rikiwarren, Jake Norwood, Bankuei, Bob Richter.

12/21/2002 Jake Norwood: Going out of town
I'll be vacationing (ahh...) until the 2nd, which means I'll be a tad sparse around here. Behave yourselves and have fun. And enjoy the new stuff at www.theriddleofsteel.net/support Jake
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Jake Norwood.

12/21/2002 Aaron: TheThingsTheySay
I found something one of my players said tonight at the conclusion of our TROS session pretty funny and felt the urge to share it with everyone. With any luck…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Aaron, allahlav.

12/21/2002 Ville: Healing times
Bear with me here... I have always loved one thing about WOTC/TSR products: The Drow and their culture. It actually provided a chance for intrigue and roleplay besides the hack…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Ville, Lyrax, Brian Leybourne, Psychopompous.

12/23/2002 prophet118: First Game, and Thoughts Thereof
well, ran my first real game of TROS last night, i wont bore you with details of the game itself, but fr the most part i avoided combat last night...…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: prophet118, Irmo, Bob Richter, Jabberwocky, Brian Leybourne, Wolfen, Lyrax, Mokkurkalfe, Ron Edwards, Jake Norwood, contracycle, svenlein, Durgil, Valamir, Jasper, Ashren Va'Hale.

12/23/2002 rikiwarren: Random thoughts on magic...
While I'm still rather new to TROS (I've made characters, and I'm dying to try it out, but I haven't played it yet. Mostly due to a lack of good…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: rikiwarren, Wolfen, Bob Richter, prophet118, Henry Fitch, Jake Norwood, contracycle, Brian Leybourne.

12/24/2002 Brian Leybourne: Merry Christmas
Well, it's probably still xmas eve for most of you, but it's a beautiful sunny christmas morning here, and we're off to the beach for a swim. Merry Christmas all,…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Brian Leybourne.

12/26/2002 Limbo: Thinking of buying -- two concerns about combat
I'm an old time player of AD&D and GURPS and haven't played for almost 15 years now. My son is getting old enough to play now though and I thought…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Limbo, Brian Leybourne, ShaneNINE, Aaron, samspectre, Alan, Ron Edwards, toli, Ashren Va'Hale, Wolfen, Jake Norwood, Michael Tree.

12/28/2002 Henry Fitch: The book is sweet! I have a bunch of questions!
So, I finally got the book a few days ago. It rocks. Really, really hard. But now I have a bunch of questions. Some of these have probably been answered…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Henry Fitch, Wolfen, Bob Richter, Jake Norwood.

12/30/2002 Ron Edwards: Asoka
What a weird movie. I mean, you have ... - This hard-core, operatic, empire-toppling plot going on. Grim and horrific and blood-stained, broken hearts everywhere. Marriages to the wrong people,…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Ron Edwards, Brian Leybourne, wraeththu, Jake Norwood, Bankuei.

1/4/2003 rikiwarren: A (hopefully) less controversial question on Magic
Hey, I touched on this in my previous post, and I was wondering how others have interpreted these. In the description on durations there is a distinction made between instant…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: rikiwarren, Brian Leybourne, prophet118, Jabberwocky, Bob Richter.

1/5/2003 Shadeling: Seven Vows of the Prophet...
Do they think magic is bad like the Imperial religion? Also, in what ways would the Tataar Horde taint the religion...Any thoughts?
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Shadeling, Jake Norwood, Brian Leybourne.

1/7/2003 Shadeling: Gelure national modifiers
I was curious about the Geluroise national modifiers in the book. It says gifted recieve +3 proficiency points-these would go into vagaries they buy, correct? It then says anyone with…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Shadeling, Bob Richter, prophet118, Jake Norwood, Henry Fitch.

1/7/2003 Shadeling: Talisman Gift...
Does the Talisman give bonus dice to each Sorcery roll or just to the sorcery pool?
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Shadeling, Jake Norwood, Ace, Brian Leybourne.

1/7/2003 Brian Leybourne: The riddle of sorceror?
Hmm.. now that's an interesting thought. The Riddle of Steel is a cool game. Sorcerer (the Ron Edwards one; I'm not talking about the White Wolf game) is also a…
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Brian Leybourne, prophet118, Ron Edwards, Valamir, Jake Norwood, Henry Fitch, Asaraludu, rikiwarren.

1/7/2003 Shadeling: What type of horse is a Stahlnish Shire Horse?
I was just curious if it was a Charger or Destrier...
In The Riddle of Steel
Participants: Shadeling, toli, Jake Norwood, Akuma, Warboss Grock, Wolfen, Draigh, Valamir, Irmo, Farseer415, Mike Holmes, Crusader.

more subsequent topics >>